Zhou H, Wang R J, Liu Z J, Liu X G, Wu F L, Dang L, Wei F
Department of Orthopaedics, Peking University Third Hospital; Engineering Research Center of Bone and Joint Precision Medicine; Beijing Key Laboratory of Spinal Disease Research, Beijing 100191, China.
Beijing Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2023 Feb 18;55(1):144-148. doi: 10.19723/j.issn.1671-167X.2023.01.022.
To investigate whether 3D-printed artificial vertebral body can reduce prosthesis subsidence rate for patients with cervical chordomas, through comparing the rates of prosthesis subsidence between 3D printing artificial vertebral body and titanium mesh for anterior spinal reconstruction after total spondylectomy.
This was a retrospective analysis of patients who underwent surgical treatment for cervical chordoma at our hospital from March 2005 to September 2019. There were nine patients in the group of 3D artificial vertebral body (3D group), and 15 patients in the group of titanium mesh cage (Mesh group). The patients' characteristics and treatment data were extracted from the medical records, including age, gender, CT hounsfield unit of cervical vertebra and surgical information, such as the surgical segments, time and blood loss of surgery, frequency and degree of prosthesis subsidence after surgery. Radiographic observations of prosthesis subsidence during the follow-up, including X-rays, CT, and magnetic resonance imaging were also collected. SPSS 22.0 was used to analysis the data.
There was no significant difference between the two groups in gender, age, CT hounsfield unit, surgical segments, time of surgery, blood loss of posterior surgery and total blood loss. Blood loss of anterior surgery was 700 (300, 825) mL in 3D group and 1 500 (750, 2 800) mL in Mesh group ( < 0.05). The prosthesis subsidence during the follow-up, 3 months after surgery, there was significant difference between the two groups in mild prosthesis subsidence ( < 0.05). The vertebral height of the 3D group decreased less than 1 mm in eight cases (no prosthesis subsidence) and more than 1 mm in one case (mild prosthesis subsidence). The vertebral height of the Mesh group decreased less than 1 mm in five cases (no prosthesis subsidence), and more than 1 mm in eight cases (mild prosthesis subsidence). Two patients did not have X-rays in 3 months after surgery. There was a statistically significant difference between the two groups in the prosthesis subsidence rate at the end of 12 months ( < 0.01). The vertebral height of eight cases in the 3D group decreased less than 1 mm (no prosthesis subsidence) and one case more than 3 mm (severe prosthesis subsidence). Four of the 15 cases in the Mesh group decreased less than 1 mm (no prosthesis subsidence), two cases more than 1 mm (mild prosthesis subsidence), and nine cases more than 3 mm (severe prosthesis subsidence). There was a statistically significant difference between the two groups in the prosthesis subsidence rate at the end of 24 months ( < 0.01). The vertebral height of seven cases in the 3D group decreased less than 1 mm (no prosthesis subsidence), one case more than 3 mm (severe prosthesis subsidence), and one case died with tumor. One case in the Mesh group decreased less than 1 mm (no prosthesis subsidence), one case more than 1 mm (mild prosthesis subsidence), 11 case more than 3 mm (severe prosthesis subsidence), one case died with tumor and one lost the follow-up. Moreover, at the end of 12 months and 24 months, there was significant difference between the two groups in severe prosthesis subsidence rate ( < 0.01).
3D-printed artificial vertebral body for anterior spinal reconstruction after total spondylectomy for patients with cervical chordoma can provide reliable spinal stability, and reduce the incidence of prosthesis subsidence after 2-year follow-up.
通过比较3D打印人工椎体与钛网在颈椎脊索瘤全脊椎切除术后前路脊柱重建中的假体下沉率,探讨3D打印人工椎体能否降低颈椎脊索瘤患者的假体下沉率。
对2005年3月至2019年9月在我院接受颈椎脊索瘤手术治疗的患者进行回顾性分析。3D人工椎体组(3D组)9例,钛网笼组(Mesh组)15例。从病历中提取患者的特征和治疗数据,包括年龄、性别、颈椎CT亨氏单位以及手术信息,如手术节段、手术时间和出血量、术后假体下沉的频率和程度。还收集了随访期间假体下沉的影像学观察资料,包括X线、CT和磁共振成像。采用SPSS 22.0进行数据分析。
两组在性别、年龄、CT亨氏单位、手术节段、手术时间、后路手术出血量和总出血量方面无显著差异。3D组前路手术出血量为700(300,825)mL,Mesh组为1 500(750,2 800)mL(P<0.05)。随访期间的假体下沉情况,术后3个月,两组在轻度假体下沉方面有显著差异(P<0.05)。3D组椎体高度下降小于1 mm的有8例(无假体下沉),大于1 mm的有1例(轻度假体下沉)。Mesh组椎体高度下降小于1 mm的有5例(无假体下沉),大于1 mm的有8例(轻度假体下沉)。3D组有2例患者术后3个月未行X线检查。两组在12个月时的假体下沉率有统计学差异(P<0.01)。3D组8例椎体高度下降小于1 mm(无假体下沉),1例大于3 mm(重度假体下沉)。Mesh组15例中4例椎体高度下降小于1 mm(无假体下沉),2例大于1 mm(轻度假体下沉),9例大于3 mm(重度假体下沉)。两组在24个月时的假体下沉率有统计学差异(P<0.01)。3D组7例椎体高度下降小于1 mm(无假体下沉),1例大于3 mm(重度假体下沉),1例死于肿瘤。Mesh组1例椎体高度下降小于1 mm(无假体下沉),1例大于1 mm(轻度假体下沉),11例大于3 mm(重度假体下沉),1例死于肿瘤,1例失访。此外,在12个月和24个月时,两组在重度假体下沉率方面有显著差异(P<0.01)。
3D打印人工椎体用于颈椎脊索瘤全脊椎切除术后前路脊柱重建可提供可靠的脊柱稳定性,并降低2年随访后的假体下沉发生率。