The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, USA.
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Health Educ Behav. 2023 Apr;50(2):181-192. doi: 10.1177/10901981221148959. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
The experiences of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) parents of children with developmental disabilities (DDs) in health and early learning systems are largely understudied. Inclusive, affirming services are critical to timely identification and intervention for DDs. This literature review aimed to establish whether LGBTQ parents experience structural bias and discrimination when accessing care for their children in health and early learning systems.
PubMed, ERIC, and Scopus were searched for empirical research from 1990 to 2020 on: LGBTQ; parents, children, families; bias, disparities, discrimination; and health and early learning services. Themes were analyzed by conceptual model bias levels, participant type, and setting.
The search yielded 1,872 unduplicated records (three through hand search). Twenty-nine articles representing 26 studies in health and early learning in eight countries met the inclusion criteria. Biases common across sectors included challenges surrounding LGBTQ status disclosures; lack of acknowledgment of non-biological parents; and heterosexist forms. Knowledge gaps and negative attitudes about LGBTQ families were found among some professionals and students.
Some LGBTQ parents experienced bias and discrimination while accessing care for their children in health and early learning systems. Policies and programs to implement and monitor LGBTQ-inclusive health education and evaluate practice changes are recommended to improve professionals' knowledge, attitudes, and behavior. Multilevel workforce development (e.g., accreditation standards, organizational audits, and training) is needed to create and sustain LGBTQ-affirming health and education environments. Honoring LGBTQ family diversity and reducing health and early learning inequities are critical for improving children's health and education outcomes.
儿童发育障碍(DD)同性恋、双性恋、跨性别和酷儿(LGBTQ)父母在健康和早期学习系统中的经历在很大程度上尚未得到充分研究。包容和肯定的服务对于及时识别和干预 DD 至关重要。本文献综述旨在确定 LGBTQ 父母在健康和早期学习系统中为子女寻求护理时是否会经历结构性偏见和歧视。
从 1990 年到 2020 年,在 PubMed、ERIC 和 Scopus 上搜索了关于以下方面的实证研究:LGBTQ;父母、儿童、家庭;偏见、差异、歧视;以及健康和早期学习服务。通过概念模型偏见水平、参与者类型和设置分析主题。
搜索产生了 1872 条不重复记录(通过手动搜索获得了 3 条记录)。符合纳入标准的 29 篇文章代表了 8 个国家在健康和早期学习领域的 26 项研究。各部门普遍存在的偏见包括围绕 LGBTQ 身份披露的挑战;不承认非亲生父母;以及异性恋形式。一些专业人员和学生发现对 LGBTQ 家庭的知识差距和负面态度。
一些 LGBTQ 父母在健康和早期学习系统中为子女寻求护理时经历了偏见和歧视。建议实施和监测 LGBTQ 包容的健康教育政策和计划,并评估实践变革,以提高专业人员的知识、态度和行为。需要多层次的劳动力发展(例如,认证标准、组织审计和培训)来创建和维持 LGBTQ 肯定的健康和教育环境。尊重 LGBTQ 家庭多样性并减少健康和早期学习方面的不平等对于改善儿童的健康和教育成果至关重要。