School of Occupational Therapy, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Dartmouth General Hospital, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada.
PLoS One. 2023 Feb 1;18(2):e0280558. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0280558. eCollection 2023.
Disclosure of LGBTQ+ identities at work may reap benefits, but may also exacerbate harms. Faced with ambiguous outcomes, people engage in complex concealment/disclosure decision-making. For health professionals, in contexts of pervasive heteronormativity where disclosure to patients/clients is deemed to violate professional boundaries, stakes are high. This qualitative study with 13 LGBTQ+ health professionals across Canada used semi-structured interviews to explore factors affecting disclosure decision-making, particularly attending to power structures at multiple levels. Most participants engaged in constant risk-benefit assessment, disclosing strategically to colleagues, rarely to clients/patients. At the individual level they were affected by degree of LGBTQ+ visibility. At the institutional level they were affected by the culture of particular professional fields and practice settings, including type of care and type of patients/clients, as well as colleague interactions. Professional power-held by them, and held by others over them-directly affected disclosures. Finally, intersections of queer identities with other privileged or marginalized identities complicated disclosures. Power relations in the health professions shape LGBTQ+ identity disclosures in complex ways, with unpredictable outcomes. Concepts of professionalism are infused with heteronormativity, serving to regulate the gender and sexual identity expression of queer professionals. Disrupting heteronormativity is essential to forge more open professional cultures.
在工作中披露 LGBTQ+身份可能会带来好处,但也可能加剧伤害。面对不确定的结果,人们会进行复杂的隐瞒/披露决策。对于医疗保健专业人员来说,在普遍异性恋规范的背景下,向患者/客户披露被认为违反了专业界限,因此风险很高。这项在加拿大进行的针对 13 名 LGBTQ+医疗保健专业人员的定性研究使用半结构化访谈来探讨影响披露决策的因素,特别关注多层次的权力结构。大多数参与者都在不断地进行风险-收益评估,与同事进行策略性披露,很少向客户/患者披露。在个人层面上,他们受到 LGBTQ+可见度的影响。在机构层面上,他们受到特定专业领域和实践环境的文化影响,包括护理类型和患者/客户类型,以及同事之间的互动。专业权力——他们拥有,以及他人对他们拥有——直接影响披露。最后,酷儿身份与其他特权或边缘化身份的交叉使披露变得复杂。医疗保健专业中的权力关系以复杂的方式影响 LGBTQ+身份的披露,结果难以预测。专业精神的概念充满了异性恋规范,旨在规范酷儿专业人员的性别和性身份表达。打破异性恋规范对于形成更开放的专业文化至关重要。