Berckemeyer Manuela Aramburu, Suarez-Meade Paola, Carcelen Maria Fernanda Villamonte, Ricci Mariel Dyer, Cheshire William P, Trifiletti Daniel M, Middlebrooks Erik H, Quinones-Hinojosa Alfredo, Grewal Sanjeet S
School of Medicine, Faculty of Biomedical Science and Health, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Department of Neurological Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA.
Neurosurg Rev. 2023 Feb 2;46(1):47. doi: 10.1007/s10143-023-01948-y.
Glossopharyngeal neuralgia (GPN) is a neurological condition characterized by paroxysmal, stabbing-like pain along the distribution of the glossopharyngeal nerve that lasts from a couple of seconds to minutes. Pharmacological treatment with anticonvulsants is the first line of treatment; however, about 25% of patients remain symptomatic and require surgical intervention, which is usually done via microvascular decompression (MVD) with or without rhizotomy. More recently, the use of stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) has been utilized as an alternative treatment method to relieve patient symptoms by causing nerve ablation. We conducted a systematic review to analyze whether MVD without rhizotomy is an equally effective treatment for GPN as MVD with the use of concurrent rhizotomy. Moreover, we sought to explore if SRS, a minimally invasive alternative surgical option, achieves comparable outcomes. We included retrospective studies and case reports in our search. We consulted PubMed and Medline, including articles from the year 2000 onwards. A total of 36 articles were included for review. Of all included patients with glossopharyngeal neuralgia, the most common offending artery compressing the glossopharyngeal nerve was the posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA). MVD alone was successful achieving pain relief immediately postoperatively in about 85% of patients, and also long term in 65-90% of patients. The most common complication found on MVD surgery was found to be transient hoarseness and transient dysphagia. Rhizotomy alone shows an instant pain relief in 85-100% of the patients, but rate of long-term pain relief was lower compared to MVD. The most common adverse effects observed after a rhizotomy were dysphagia and dysesthesia along the distribution of the glossopharyngeal nerve. SRS had promising results in pain reduction when using 75 Gy radiation or higher; however, long-term rates of pain relief were lower. MVD, rhizotomy, and SRS are effective methods to treat GPN as they help achieve instant pain relief and the decrease use of medication. Patients with MVD alone presented with less adverse effects than the group that underwent MVD plus rhizotomy. Although SRS may be a viable alternative treatment for GPN, further studies must be done to evaluate long-term treatment efficacy.
舌咽神经痛(GPN)是一种神经系统疾病,其特征为沿舌咽神经分布区域出现阵发性、刺痛样疼痛,持续数秒至数分钟。使用抗惊厥药物进行药物治疗是一线治疗方法;然而,约25%的患者仍有症状,需要手术干预,通常通过微血管减压术(MVD)进行,可联合或不联合神经根切断术。最近,立体定向放射外科手术(SRS)已被用作一种替代治疗方法,通过引起神经消融来缓解患者症状。我们进行了一项系统综述,以分析不进行神经根切断术的MVD治疗GPN是否与使用同期神经根切断术的MVD同样有效。此外,我们试图探讨SRS这种微创替代手术选择是否能取得可比的效果。我们在检索中纳入了回顾性研究和病例报告。我们查阅了PubMed和Medline,包括2000年起的文章。共纳入36篇文章进行综述。在所有纳入的舌咽神经痛患者中,压迫舌咽神经最常见的责任动脉是小脑后下动脉(PICA)。单纯MVD术后约85%的患者立即成功缓解疼痛,65 - 90%的患者长期疼痛缓解。MVD手术中最常见的并发症是短暂性声音嘶哑和短暂性吞咽困难。单纯神经根切断术在85 - 100%的患者中可立即缓解疼痛,但与MVD相比,长期疼痛缓解率较低。神经根切断术后观察到的最常见不良反应是吞咽困难和沿舌咽神经分布区域的感觉异常。使用75 Gy或更高剂量辐射时,SRS在减轻疼痛方面有令人鼓舞的结果;然而,长期疼痛缓解率较低。MVD、神经根切断术和SRS都是治疗GPN的有效方法,因为它们有助于立即缓解疼痛并减少药物使用。单纯接受MVD的患者出现的不良反应比接受MVD加神经根切断术的组少。虽然SRS可能是GPN的一种可行替代治疗方法,但必须进行进一步研究以评估长期治疗效果。