Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Ankara University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Türkiye.
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Ankara University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Türkiye -
Eur J Phys Rehabil Med. 2023 Apr;59(2):259-269. doi: 10.23736/S1973-9087.22.07833-9. Epub 2023 Feb 2.
The aim of this paper was to provide an overview of Cochrane Systematic Reviews (CSRs), which synthesizes the quality and quantity of available evidence on the effectiveness of rehabilitation interventions in rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The World Health Organization (WHO) requested Cochrane Rehabilitation the CSRs search to develop the Package of Interventions in Rehabilitation (PIR). We searched the Cochrane Library using the terms "rheumatoid arthritis" and "rehabilitation." We screened the CSRs according to the search strategy based on the methodology developed for the WHO PIR. The search period for the data provided to WHO was between 1 September 2009 and 2019. We updated the search to 1 September 2022 for this paper. We summarized the CSRs identified after the screening process using an evidence map, grouping outcomes, and comparisons of included CSRs indicating the effect and the quality of evidence to provide a comprehensive view of current knowledge. We identified 10 CSRs, including 92 primary studies with 10,801 participants and 23 comparisons. They explored the effectiveness and/or safety of either non-pharmacological or pharmacological (for symptom control only) interventions. Outcomes were pain, muscle strength, grip/pinch strength, tender joints, swollen joints, fatigue, disease activity, radiological damage, physical function, hand function, participant adherence, clinical improvement, withdrawals, and adverse events. Our mapping synthesis indicates that physical activity and exercises in RA are effective non-pharmacological interventions for some outcomes, such as hand function, muscle strength and fatigue, without any deterioration of pain, disease activity and radiological involvement. Psychosocial interventions show a small beneficial effect on fatigue. Regarding pharmacological agents, celecoxib presents similar analgesic effects with traditional NSAIDs but fewer gastric adverse events. Current evidence supports physical activity and exercise programs for individuals with RA. However, well-designed studies will help document the exact effects of these programs on different outcomes and physiological mechanisms in RA. There were inconclusive results for some of the interventions due to low and very-low quality of evidence. Furthermore, due to the lack of CSRs on therapeutic patient education, orthoses, physical modalities and assistive devices in the search period, it was impossible to synthesise the evidence on those interventions.
本文旨在概述 Cochrane 系统评价 (CSRs),综合评估类风湿关节炎 (RA)康复干预措施有效性的现有证据的质量和数量。世界卫生组织 (WHO) 要求 Cochrane 康复部门根据 Package of Interventions in Rehabilitation (PIR) 进行 CSRs 检索。我们使用“rheumatoid arthritis”和“rehabilitation”这两个术语在 Cochrane 图书馆中进行检索。我们根据针对 WHO PIR 开发的方法学制定的检索策略筛选 CSRs。向 WHO 提供数据的检索期间为 2009 年 9 月 1 日至 2019 年。本文更新了检索,截至 2022 年 9 月 1 日。我们使用证据图总结筛选后确定的 CSRs,对包括的 CSRs 的结果和比较进行分组,以表明效果和证据质量,从而提供当前知识的全面视图。我们确定了 10 项 CSRs,其中包括 92 项初级研究,涉及 10801 名参与者和 23 项比较。它们探索了非药物或药物干预(仅用于症状控制)的有效性和/或安全性。结果包括疼痛、肌肉力量、握力/捏力、压痛关节、肿胀关节、疲劳、疾病活动度、放射学损伤、身体功能、手部功能、参与者依从性、临床改善、退出和不良事件。我们的映射综合表明,体育活动和锻炼是 RA 的有效非药物干预措施,对某些结果(如手部功能、肌肉力量和疲劳)有效,而不会导致疼痛、疾病活动度和放射学受累恶化。心理社会干预对疲劳有较小的有益影响。关于药物制剂,塞来昔布在镇痛效果上与传统 NSAIDs 相似,但胃肠道不良反应较少。目前的证据支持针对 RA 患者的体育活动和锻炼计划。然而,需要精心设计的研究来帮助记录这些计划对 RA 不同结果和生理机制的确切影响。由于证据质量低和极低,一些干预措施的结果存在不确定性。此外,由于在检索期间缺乏关于治疗性患者教育、矫形器、物理疗法和辅助设备的 CSRs,因此无法综合这些干预措施的证据。