Yabar Carlos Augusto
Dev World Bioeth. 2024 Jun;24(2):97-101. doi: 10.1111/dewb.12391. Epub 2023 Feb 3.
Effective vaccines for COVID-19 are already available to humankind. In Peru, 86 million doses were administered to cover the demand for 33 million Peruvian people. Hence, vaccination has been prioritized in groups: health personnel, subjects with pre-existing health conditions and those over 65 years of age. However, given the social problems and the public health situation in Peru, this work defends that the priority of vaccination should be focused on the population living in extreme poverty. The method used was an ethical argumentation on the distribution of scarce antiSARS-CoV2 vaccine in Peru. This argument is based on the analysis of the Peruvian population living in extreme poverty, which presents different layers of vulnerability, and that, in the face of an eventual SARS-CoV2 infection, these would be exacerbated one after the other, through a cascade effect. This scenario would give rise to new vulnerabilities to those already existing, causing greater damage. Vaccination efforts on this key population would give them the opportunity to continue to find ways to bring food to their homes, significantly reducing the risk of contagion in their environment and mitigating the devastating effect of the local diseases to which they are already exposed. Four objections related to this argument are raised with their corresponding responses. Priority access to the vaccine would significantly reduce the humanitarian harm to people living in extreme poverty, prevailing the principles of justice and equity.
针对新冠病毒的有效疫苗已可供人类使用。在秘鲁,已接种8600万剂疫苗,以满足3300万秘鲁人的需求。因此,疫苗接种按群体划分了优先级:卫生人员、有既往健康问题的人群以及65岁以上的老年人。然而,鉴于秘鲁的社会问题和公共卫生状况,本研究主张疫苗接种的优先级应集中在生活在极端贫困中的人群。所采用的方法是对秘鲁稀缺的抗SARS-CoV-2疫苗分配进行伦理论证。这一论证基于对生活在极端贫困中的秘鲁人口的分析,他们呈现出不同层次的脆弱性,并且面对最终的SARS-CoV-2感染,这些脆弱性会通过级联效应一个接一个地加剧。这种情况会给已有的脆弱性带来新的问题,造成更大的损害。对这一关键人群的疫苗接种工作将使他们有机会继续想办法把食物带回家,显著降低其周围环境中的传染风险,并减轻他们已经面临的当地疾病的破坏性影响。针对这一论证提出了四个反对意见并给出了相应回应。优先获得疫苗将显著减少对生活在极端贫困中的人们的人道主义伤害,正义和平等原则将得以盛行。