Lee Ciara Ann, Wilkinson Timothy James, Timmermans Julie Anita, Ali Anthony Naushad, Anakin Megan Grayce
Department of General Practice and Rural Health at the Dunedin School of Medicine, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand.
Medicine and Medical Education at the University of Otago, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Med Educ. 2023 Aug;57(8):761-769. doi: 10.1111/medu.15026. Epub 2023 Feb 14.
In health professions education, faculty may feel frustrated or challenged by aspects of their teaching. The concept of a hidden curriculum for students describes the expectations and assumptions enacted in educational programmes that tacitly impact students' learning experiences. A hidden curriculum has been suggested as a possible influence on faculty but has not been well explored. The aim of this study was to explain how a hidden curriculum might operate for faculty in health professions education.
An interpretivist perspective was used to frame this qualitative study that examined one-on-one interview data generated with 16 faculty members from six different health care professions. Participants were asked to describe teaching experiences that they perceived as demanding. Using a hidden curriculum framework, descriptions of demanding teaching experiences were analysed inductively to identify relationships between a teacher's intended practice and what they could accomplish. These relationships were interpreted as the possible ways that a hidden curriculum was operating for faculty.
A hidden curriculum for faculty was found to operate in three ways by undervaluing the importance of having teaching expertise, undermining teaching goals through institutional conventions and perpetuating feelings of isolation.
A hidden curriculum for faculty can be represented as multiple overlapping domains and shape how faculty experience their teaching roles. The results provide examples that reveal how a hidden curriculum may operate for faculty. Faculty developers may find the insights provided by this study useful to make the hidden curriculum visible and help their faculty make sense of and navigate demanding teaching experiences.
在卫生专业教育中,教师可能会对教学的某些方面感到沮丧或面临挑战。针对学生的隐性课程概念描述了教育计划中所实施的期望和假设,这些期望和假设会潜移默化地影响学生的学习体验。有人提出隐性课程可能会对教师产生影响,但尚未得到充分探讨。本研究的目的是解释隐性课程在卫生专业教育中可能如何影响教师。
本定性研究采用解释主义视角,分析了来自六个不同卫生保健专业的16名教师的一对一访谈数据。参与者被要求描述他们认为具有挑战性的教学经历。使用隐性课程框架,对具有挑战性的教学经历描述进行归纳分析,以确定教师的预期实践与他们实际能够完成的事情之间的关系。这些关系被解释为隐性课程可能影响教师的方式。
发现影响教师的隐性课程通过三种方式发挥作用,即低估教学专业知识的重要性、通过机构惯例破坏教学目标以及使孤立感长期存在。
影响教师的隐性课程可以表现为多个重叠的领域,并塑造教师对其教学角色的体验。研究结果提供了一些例子,揭示了隐性课程可能如何影响教师。教师发展人员可能会发现本研究提供的见解有助于使隐性课程变得可见,并帮助他们的教师理解并应对具有挑战性的教学经历。