Que Ning
Faculty of Table Tennis, Badminton and Tennis, Chengdu Sport University, Chengdu, China.
Front Physiol. 2023 Jan 25;14:1058637. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2023.1058637. eCollection 2023.
Kinesio taping (KT) and vibration treatment (VT) can alleviate delayed-onset muscle soreness (DOMS) to some extent. However, the literature reports on the difference between the two treatments, and whether a joint intervention (JI) works better than single treatments remains unknown. This study compares the effects of KT, VT and JI on DOMS in college students. A total of 88 college students were randomly divided into the KT (KTG, n = 21), VT (VTG, n = 22), JI (JIG, n = 23) and control (CG, n = 22) groups. All subjects underwent DOMS moulding. The baseline; immediate and 24, 48 and 72 h visual analogue scale (VAS) scores and knee extensor maximum isometric voluntary contraction (MIVC) were determined. The intergroup comparison showed the following results. 1) The VAS scores of the four groups peaked at 24 h and gradually decreased. The immediate, 24 h and 48 h VAS scores followed the order: JIG > KTG and VTG > CG. The 72 h VAS score followed the order: KTG < VTG < JIG < CG. 2) The knee extension MIVC in the four groups was lowest at 24 h and then gradually increased. JIG had larger immediate MIVC than CG. KTG, VTG and JIG had larger 24 h MIVC than CG. JIG had larger 48 h MIVC than KTG and CG. KT and VT can reduce muscle pain and strength loss caused by DOMS to varying degrees. VT is better than KT in improving pain. The combined intervention worked better than single interventions.
肌内效贴扎(KT)和振动治疗(VT)在一定程度上可缓解延迟性肌肉酸痛(DOMS)。然而,关于这两种治疗方法差异的文献报道较少,联合干预(JI)是否比单一治疗效果更好仍不清楚。本研究比较了KT、VT和JI对大学生DOMS的影响。88名大学生被随机分为KT组(KTG,n = 21)、VT组(VTG,n = 22)、JI组(JIG,n = 23)和对照组(CG,n = 22)。所有受试者均进行DOMS造模。测定基线、即刻以及24、48和72小时的视觉模拟评分(VAS)和膝关节伸肌最大等长自主收缩(MIVC)。组间比较结果如下:1)四组VAS评分均在24小时达到峰值,随后逐渐下降。即刻、24小时和48小时VAS评分顺序为:JIG > KTG和VTG > CG。72小时VAS评分顺序为:KTG < VTG < JIG < CG。2)四组膝关节伸展MIVC均在24小时最低,随后逐渐升高。JIG组即刻MIVC大于CG组。KTG、VTG和JIG组24小时MIVC大于CG组。JIG组48小时MIVC大于KTG组和CG组。KT和VT均可不同程度减轻DOMS引起的肌肉疼痛和力量损失。VT在改善疼痛方面优于KT。联合干预效果优于单一干预。