Henk J M, James K W
Clin Radiol. 1978 Nov;29(6):611-6. doi: 10.1016/s0009-9260(78)80180-9.
A random controlled trial was performed to compare long and short fractionation of radiotherapy in patients with head and neck cancer with a poor prognosis. Ninety-eight matched pairs were treated, one member of each pair received 10 fractions in 22 days, the other 30 fractions in 42 days. The same nominal standard dosages were used in each arm of the trial. Mucosal reactions were more severe with 10 fractions, skin reactions more severe with 30 fractions. No difference in survival, local tumour control rates or late normal tissue effects could be demonstrated. It is suggested that any possible therapeutic advantage of prolonged fractionation is minimal and that it is justified to use a small number of large fractions in clinical trials involving hyperbaric oxygen or electron-affinic sensitizers.
进行了一项随机对照试验,以比较预后不良的头颈癌患者放疗的长疗程分割与短疗程分割。治疗了98对匹配患者,每对中的一名患者在22天内接受10次分割照射,另一名在42天内接受30次分割照射。试验的每个组均使用相同的标称标准剂量。10次分割照射时黏膜反应更严重,30次分割照射时皮肤反应更严重。在生存率、局部肿瘤控制率或晚期正常组织效应方面未显示出差异。提示延长分割照射的任何可能治疗优势极小,在涉及高压氧或亲电子敏化剂的临床试验中使用少量大分割照射是合理的。