Mohebbi Mohammad, Nafissi Nastaran, Ghotbani Farzaneh, Khojasteh Zonoozi Arash, Mohaddes Ardabili Hossein
Student Research Committee, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences Research Center, Faculty of Medicine, Ibn-e-Sina Hospital, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Front Psychiatry. 2023 Jan 26;13:1027377. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.1027377. eCollection 2022.
Psychiatry is facing one of the highest levels of shortages among medical specialties. Stigma toward psychiatry plays an influential role in medical students' decision to choose psychiatry as a career and has been reported to be prevalent in different parts of the world, particularly in low/middle-income countries.
To systematically review the Eastern Mediterranean Region (EMR) medical students' attitudes toward psychiatry, to assess whether their attitudes are stigmatized or not, and the factors affecting their attitudes.
PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and PsychInfo (PsycARTICLES) were searched using a combination of main terms "stigma," "psychiatry," "medical students," and the name of Eastern Mediterranean countries. Cross-sectional studies assessing the attitudes of EMR medical students toward psychiatry were included in this review.
Ten studies were eligible to be included in the result synthesis. These were from Pakistan ( = 3), Iran ( = 2), Saudi Arabia ( = 1), Lebanon ( = 1), Egypt ( = 1), Bahrain ( = 1), and Oman ( = 1). Most studies reported a combination of both positive and negative attitudes among medical students; however, the overall attitude was positive. Factors affecting medical students' attitude toward psychiatry included poor psychological well-being, having a friend with a psychiatric illness, involving in a romantic relationship with someone suffering from mental illness, young age, frequency of exposure to psychiatry clerkship/teaching, and quality of psychiatry clerkship. Nevertheless, the final positive or negative outcome of these factors on students' attitudes remained controversial.
Considering the lack of sufficient data from most EMR countries, we need to exercise caution in interpreting the results of this review. Nevertheless, our review indicates that psychiatry is not stigmatized among EMR medical students, and they have generally positive attitudes toward it. The findings of studies evaluating influencing factors are contradictory and demand further exploration.
精神病学面临着医学专业中最为严重的人才短缺问题之一。对精神病学的污名化在医学生选择精神病学作为职业的决定中起着重要作用,并且据报道在世界不同地区普遍存在,尤其是在低收入/中等收入国家。
系统评价东地中海区域(EMR)医学生对精神病学的态度,评估他们的态度是否存在污名化,以及影响他们态度的因素。
使用主要术语“污名化”“精神病学”“医学生”以及东地中海国家的名称进行组合检索,检索了PubMed、Scopus、科学网和PsychInfo(PsycARTICLES)。本综述纳入了评估EMR医学生对精神病学态度的横断面研究。
有10项研究符合纳入结果综合分析的条件。这些研究分别来自巴基斯坦(3项)、伊朗(2项)、沙特阿拉伯(1项)、黎巴嫩(1项)、埃及(1项)、巴林(1项)和阿曼(1项)。大多数研究报告称医学生中既有积极态度也有消极态度;然而,总体态度是积极的。影响医学生对精神病学态度的因素包括心理健康状况不佳、有患精神疾病的朋友、与患有精神疾病的人恋爱、年龄较小、接触精神病学实习/教学的频率以及精神病学实习的质量。然而,这些因素对学生态度的最终积极或消极结果仍存在争议。
鉴于大多数EMR国家缺乏足够的数据,我们在解释本综述的结果时需要谨慎。尽管如此,我们的综述表明,在EMR医学生中,精神病学并未受到污名化,他们总体上对其持积极态度。评估影响因素的研究结果相互矛盾,需要进一步探索。