Karamustafalıoğlu Oguz K, Fostick Leah, Çevik Mehmet, Zukerman Gil, Tankaya Onur, Güveli Mustafa, Bakım Banadir, Karamustafalıoğlu Nesrin, Zohar Joseph
Istanbul University Forensic Sciences Institute, Istanbul, Turkey.
These authors contributed equally to this work.
J Clin Psychiatry. 2023 Feb 20;84(2):22m14377. doi: 10.4088/JCP.22m14377.
Few earthquake survivor studies extend follow-up beyond 2 years, leaving the long-term course of earthquake-related posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) unknown. This 10-year survey re-assessed the 1999 İzmit, Turkey, earthquake survivors. İzmit earthquake survivors (N = 198), previously assessed for PTSD/partial PTSD at 1-3 months and 18-20 months post-earthquake, were evaluated 10 years post-event from January 2009 through December 2010. A PTSD self-test (Turkish translation) used criteria to characterize full PTSD, "stringent partial PTSD," "lenient partial PTSD," or non-PTSD based on symptom type/amount. Full PTSD prevalence decreased from 37% at 1-3 months post-earthquake to 15% at 18-20 months ( < .001), remaining relatively stable (12%) at 10 years ( = .38). Stringent and lenient partial PTSD decreased between 1-3 months and 18-20 months (from 9% to 3% and from 24% to 12%, respectively; < .001), remaining stable at 10 years (5% and 9%, respectively; = .43 and = .89). PTSD was more prevalent at 1-3 months among those who had a close acquaintance harmed, had been evacuated for long periods (> 1 week), or had more children; this was not observed at 10 years ( = .007-.017). Avoidance symptoms 1-3 months post-earthquake were the best predictor for full PTSD at 10 years ( < .001). Delayed-onset PTSD was observed in only 2% of participants. Full and partial PTSD decreased over the first 2 years post-trauma, but remained stable at 10 years, suggesting PTSD symptoms at around 2 years remain stable at 10 years. Background characteristics did not predict PTSD long-term course, but avoidance level did. Delayed-onset PTSD was relatively rare.
很少有地震幸存者研究将随访时间延长至两年以上,因此与地震相关的创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的长期病程尚不清楚。这项为期10年的调查对1999年土耳其伊兹密特地震的幸存者进行了重新评估。2009年1月至2010年12月,对伊兹密特地震幸存者(N = 198)进行了事件发生10年后的评估,这些幸存者在地震后1 - 3个月和18 - 20个月曾接受过PTSD/部分PTSD评估。一项PTSD自我测试(土耳其语翻译版)根据症状类型/数量,使用标准来界定完全PTSD、“严格部分PTSD”、“宽松部分PTSD”或非PTSD。完全PTSD的患病率从地震后1 - 3个月时的37%降至18 - 20个月时的15%(<0.001),在10年时保持相对稳定(12%)(=0.38)。严格和宽松部分PTSD在1 - 3个月至18 - 20个月之间有所下降(分别从9%降至3%和从24%降至12%;<0.001),在10年时保持稳定(分别为5%和9%;=0.43和=0.89)。在那些有亲密熟人受伤、被疏散很长时间(>1周)或孩子较多的人中,PTSD在1 - 3个月时更为普遍;在10年时未观察到这种情况(=0.007 - 0.017)。地震后1 - 3个月的回避症状是10年后完全PTSD的最佳预测指标(<0.001)。仅2%的参与者出现延迟性PTSD。完全和部分PTSD在创伤后的头两年有所下降,但在10年时保持稳定,这表明创伤后约2年时的PTSD症状在10年时保持稳定。背景特征无法预测PTSD的长期病程,但回避程度可以。延迟性PTSD相对罕见。