School of Physical Education and Sport Science, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece.
Theseus, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Center, Athens, Greece.
Eur J Sport Sci. 2023 Jul;23(7):1164-1174. doi: 10.1080/17461391.2023.2184726. Epub 2023 Mar 18.
The aim of the present study was to compare the effect of chronic concentric or eccentric training on position sense and joint reaction angle, in healthy, untrained young men. Twenty-four men were randomly assigned into a pure concentric (CT) or a pure eccentric (ET) group and performed for 8 weeks, one training session/week, 75 maximal knee extensors contractions. Before and 48 h after the first (W1) and the last (W8) training sessions, knee joint position sense and joint reaction angle were assessed at three different knee angles (i.e. 30°, 45° and 60°). At the same time points, indirect indices of exercise-induced muscle damage (EIMD) were evaluated (i.e. range of motion [ROM], optimal angle, maximum isometric, concentric and eccentric torques, delayed onset muscle soreness [DOMS] and blood creatine kinase concentrations [CK]). Forty-eight hours post W1, position sense, reaction angle and all EIMD indices were significantly changed for both groups ( < 0.05; η: 0.125-0.618), however, greater alterations were observed after ET. Significant correlations were found, in both groups, between the training-induced changes of position sense, reaction angles and the changes of EIMD biomarkers (: -0.855-0.825; < 0.005). No significant changes were found 48 h post W8 for position sense, reaction angle and EIMD indices ( > 0.285) for both CT or ET groups. In conclusion, exercise-induced changes in position sense and reaction angle, were related to the magnitude of EIMD, and not by the type of muscle contraction .Exercise induced changes in position sense and reaction angle, were related to the magnitude of EIMD, and not by the type of muscle contraction .After the 1st training session eccentric exercise caused greater disturbances, compared to concentric exercise, in EIMD indices which caused concomitant disturbances to position sense and knee reaction angle.8 weeks of either eccentric or concentric training leads to preservation of position sense and knee reaction angle 48 h after maximal intensity exercise of either types of muscle contraction.
本研究旨在比较慢性向心或离心训练对健康、未经训练的年轻男性位置感和关节反应角的影响。24 名男性被随机分配到纯向心(CT)或纯离心(ET)组,并进行 8 周,每周 1 次训练,每次 75 次最大膝关节伸肌收缩。在第一次(W1)和最后一次(W8)训练后 48 小时,评估了三个不同膝关节角度(即 30°、45°和 60°)的膝关节位置感和关节反应角。在同一时间点,还评估了运动诱导的肌肉损伤(EIMD)的间接指标(即运动范围[ROM]、最佳角度、最大等长、向心和离心扭矩、延迟性肌肉酸痛[DOMS]和血液肌酸激酶浓度[CK])。W1 后 48 小时,两组的位置感、反应角和所有 EIMD 指标均发生显著变化( < 0.05;η:0.125-0.618),但 ET 后变化更大。在两组中,位置感、反应角的训练诱导变化与 EIMD 生物标志物的变化之间存在显著相关性(:-0.855-0.825; < 0.005)。对于 CT 或 ET 组,W8 后 48 小时,位置感、反应角和 EIMD 指数均无显著变化( > 0.285)。总之,位置感和反应角的运动诱导变化与 EIMD 的幅度有关,而与肌肉收缩的类型无关。离心运动引起的位置感和反应角的运动诱导变化与 EIMD 的幅度有关,而与肌肉收缩的类型无关。第一次训练后,与向心运动相比,离心运动引起的 EIMD 指标变化更大,导致位置感和膝关节反应角同时受到干扰。8 周的离心或向心训练可在两种类型的肌肉收缩的最大强度运动后 48 小时保持位置感和膝关节反应角。