Habibzadeh Yasaman, Yarmohammadian Mohammad Hossein, Sadeghi-Bazargani Homayoun
Department of Health Services Management, School of Management and Medical Information Sciences, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Road Traffic Injury Research Center, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Bull Emerg Trauma. 2023;11(1):1-12. doi: 10.30476/BEAT.2023.95410.1356.
To estimate the rate of driving hazard perception (HP), explicate the content of HP and determine its components.
The present study is a systematic review and a meta-analysis which is carried out to gather data, to search Science Direct, PubMed, Scopus, PROQUEST, web of knowledge databases, Google scholar search engine and also to search manually from January 2000 to September 2021 with using related keywords. EndNote X20 software was used to manage and screening studies. Stata16 was used for meta-analysis. Thematic content analysis was used to analyze the findings. The entire review process was conducted by two authors, and disputes were referred to a third person.
Out of the 1167 founded articles, 50 were finally included in the study. According to 10 imported papers for meta-analysis includes 2770 sample size, general HP of drivers is estimated 3.33 [4.04-2.62 with CI 95, I2=89.72]. Also, HP for experienced and beginner drivers is estimated 3.26 [2.23-4.26 with CI 95, I2=89.47] and 3.42 [2.41-4.43 with CI 95, I2=89.68], respectively. Also, in the data meta-synthesis, 28 definitions of HP and 6 main components are identified to evaluate HP using thematic content analysis.
In this study, obtained results show that all people need constant and gradual training at all levels. A factor that can be effective to improve drivers' HP is to make drivers to take training courses and to pass standard tests at the time of obtaining driving license.
评估驾驶危险感知(HP)率,阐明HP的内容并确定其组成部分。
本研究是一项系统评价和荟萃分析,旨在收集数据,检索科学Direct、PubMed、Scopus、PROQUEST、知识网络数据库、谷歌学术搜索引擎,并在2000年1月至2021年9月期间使用相关关键词进行手动检索。使用EndNote X20软件管理和筛选研究。使用Stata16进行荟萃分析。采用主题内容分析法分析研究结果。整个综述过程由两位作者进行,如有争议则提交给第三人。
在1167篇检索到的文章中,最终有50篇被纳入研究。根据10篇用于荟萃分析的进口论文,样本量为2770,驾驶员的总体HP估计为3.33[95%置信区间为4.04 - 2.62,I2 = 89.72]。此外,经验丰富的驾驶员和新手驾驶员的HP估计分别为3.26[95%置信区间为2.23 - 4.26,I2 = 89.47]和3.42[95%置信区间为2.41 - 4.43,I2 = 89.68]。此外,在数据元综合中,通过主题内容分析确定了28个HP定义和6个主要组成部分来评估HP。
在本研究中,获得的结果表明,所有人都需要在各个层面进行持续且渐进的培训。一个可以有效提高驾驶员HP的因素是让驾驶员在获得驾驶执照时参加培训课程并通过标准测试。