Department of Anesthesiology, Reanimatology and Intensive Care Medicine, University Hospital Sveti Duh Zagreb, Croatia.
Catholic University of Croatia, School of Medicine, Zagreb, Croatia.
Acta Clin Croat. 2022 Sep;61(Suppl 2):41-48. doi: 10.20471/acc.2022.61.s2.05.
Quality assessment of provided healthcare is becoming a standard in numerous health institutions worldwide, which is beneficial for both the patient and the institution. In order to achieve this standard, it is necessary to develop quality indicators in all segments of healthcare. Postdural puncture headache is a common complication following neuraxial blocks, especially in obstetric anesthesia. If severe, it is a cause of emotional and psychological distress and must be treated by a blood patch.
The aim of this study was to determine whether the number of these complications is reduced when blood patch frequency is monitored and analyzed and to assess the effect of countermeasures in order to improve the quality and safety of regional anesthesia in obstetrics.
Before 2009 and during that year at the University Hospital Sveti Duh, there had been a large number of severe postdural puncture headaches after spinal anesthesia and epidural analgesia treated by a blood patch in 6.12% of cases. After noticing the rising number of blood patches, we decided to analyses data every year. We recorded all blood patches injected to obstetric patients within the period of nine year, from 2009 to 2018 and concurrently we introduced a set of measures to improve the quality of neuraxial blocks, such as the use of atraumatic 26 or 27-gauge pencil-point spinal needles and modern neuraxial blockade protocols. Data were collected from anesthesiology and gynecology protocols and analyzed with MedCalc software, version 18.1.2.
The frequency of blood patch applications has been reduced from 6.12% to 0.30%, which is statistically significant. The percentage of placed epidural catheters for vaginal birth increased from 21% in 2009 to 38% in 2018. Although not statistically significant, the number of pregnant women undergoing a caesarean section is also growing, while the total number of births is falling. The proportion of cesarean sections in spinal anesthesia varies from year to year.
A statistically significant decrease in the number of installed blood patches clearly indicates the positive effect of measures taken to improve quality, which could contribute to the growing interest of pregnant women in childbirth in epidural analgesia. The number of placed epidural catheters is increasing despite the decline in the total number of deliveries and the increase in the number of deliveries completed by cesarean section.
Monitoring the incidence of severe post-puncture headaches treated with blood patches has shown great progress in improving the quality and safety of regional anesthesia and analgesia in our institution, so we believe that monitoring the number of blood patches could serve as an indicator of regional anesthesia and analgesia in obstetrics. Monitoring the number of blood patches shows that the frequency of post-puncture headaches does not correlate only with the type of needle or epidural catheter used for neuroaxial blocks, but is also a sensitive indicator of any deviations from the achieved standards. Furthermore, it indicates the need for careful analysis of causes in order to adopt and implement appropriate countermeasures.
在全球众多医疗机构中,医疗保健质量评估正成为一项标准,这对患者和医疗机构都有益处。为了达到这一标准,有必要在医疗保健的各个环节制定质量指标。硬膜外穿刺后头痛是脊麻后常见的并发症,尤其是在产科麻醉中。如果严重,会引起情绪和心理困扰,必须进行血补丁治疗。
本研究旨在确定监测和分析血补丁频率是否会减少这些并发症的数量,并评估采取措施的效果,以提高产科区域麻醉的质量和安全性。
在 2009 年之前和当年,在圣达乌医院(University Hospital Sveti Duh),有大量严重的硬膜外穿刺后头痛,在 6.12%的情况下需要进行血补丁治疗。在注意到血补丁数量增加后,我们决定每年分析数据。我们记录了 2009 年至 2018 年九年间产科患者接受的所有血补丁注射,并同时引入了一套提高脊神经阻滞质量的措施,如使用无创伤性 26 或 27 号笔尖脊髓针和现代脊神经阻滞方案。数据从麻醉学和妇科方案中收集,并使用 MedCalc 软件版本 18.1.2 进行分析。
血补丁应用的频率已从 6.12%降至 0.30%,具有统计学意义。用于阴道分娩的硬膜外导管放置率从 2009 年的 21%增加到 2018 年的 38%。尽管没有统计学意义,但剖宫产孕妇的数量也在增加,而总分娩数量却在下降。脊髓麻醉中的剖宫产比例因年份而异。
安装血补丁数量的显著减少清楚地表明,采取措施提高质量的效果显著,这可能有助于孕妇对硬膜外分娩镇痛的兴趣增加。尽管总分娩量下降,剖宫产分娩量增加,但放置硬膜外导管的数量仍在增加。
监测使用血补丁治疗的严重穿刺后头痛发生率表明,我们机构的区域麻醉和镇痛质量得到了极大的提高,因此我们相信,监测血补丁的数量可以作为产科区域麻醉和镇痛的指标。监测血补丁的数量表明,穿刺后头痛的频率不仅与用于神经轴阻滞的针或硬膜外导管的类型相关,而且还是任何偏离既定标准的敏感指标。此外,这表明需要仔细分析原因,以便采取和实施适当的对策。