Wijayarathne Pasangi M, Ng Alexandrea, Menahem Samuel
Department of Medical Education, 2281University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Paediatrics, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia.
World J Pediatr Congenit Heart Surg. 2023 Jan;14(1):55-62. doi: 10.1177/21501351221127895.
Almost 90% of patients with congenital heart disease (CHD) now reach adulthood. How do they evaluate the care they received?
Adults with CHD (ACHD) recruited for an international multi-center study (APPROACH-IS II) were posed 3 additional "questions" to determine their perceptions of the positive, negative, and areas for improvement of their clinical care. The findings underwent a thematic analysis.
Of the 210 recruited, 183 completed the questionnaire, 147 answered the 3 "questions." Most appreciated open communication and support, a holistic approach, continuity of and readily accessible care conducted by experts, and with good outcomes. Less than half reported negative concerns which included loss of autonomy, distress from multiple and/or painful investigations, restricted lifestyles, medication side-effects, and anxiety about their CHD. Others found their reviews time-consuming with long travel times. Some complained of limited support, poor accessibility to services in rural areas, shortage of ACHD specialists, absence of tailored rehabilitation programs, and at times their own as well as their clinicians' limited understanding of their CHD. Suggestions for improvement included better communication, further education about their CHD, availability of simplified written information, mental health and support services, support groups, seamless transition to adult care and providing better prognostications, financial assistance, flexible appointments, telehealth reviews, and greater access to rural specialist care.
In addition to providing optimal medical and surgical care for ACHD, clinicians need to be cognizant of their patients' concerns and proactive in addressing them.
目前,近90%的先天性心脏病(CHD)患者已步入成年期。他们如何评价所接受的治疗?
参与一项国际多中心研究(APPROACH - IS II)的成年先天性心脏病患者(ACHD)被额外提出3个“问题”,以确定他们对临床治疗的积极、消极看法以及改进领域。对研究结果进行了主题分析。
在招募的210名患者中,183名完成了问卷,147名回答了这3个“问题”。大多数患者赞赏开放的沟通与支持、整体治疗方法、专家提供的持续且易于获得的治疗以及良好的治疗效果。不到一半的患者报告了负面担忧,包括自主权丧失、多次和/或痛苦检查带来的困扰、生活方式受限、药物副作用以及对自身先天性心脏病的焦虑。其他人则觉得复查耗时且路途遥远。一些人抱怨支持有限、农村地区难以获得服务、先天性心脏病成人专家短缺、缺乏量身定制的康复项目,以及有时他们自己和临床医生对其先天性心脏病的了解有限。改进建议包括更好的沟通、关于其先天性心脏病的进一步教育、提供简化的书面信息、心理健康和支持服务、支持小组、无缝过渡到成人护理并提供更好的预后、经济援助、灵活预约、远程医疗复查以及增加农村地区专科护理的可及性。
除了为先天性心脏病成人患者提供最佳的医疗和手术治疗外,临床医生还需要了解患者的担忧并积极解决这些问题。