Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Department of Ear, Nose & Throat, United Christian Hospital, Hong Kong, China.
Dysphagia. 2023 Oct;38(5):1363-1370. doi: 10.1007/s00455-023-10565-2. Epub 2023 Mar 4.
Puree is commonly prescribed for patients with mastication and bolus formation difficulties, but its appearance might negatively impact appetite and intake. Molded puree is marketed to be an alternative to traditional puree, but the process of molding puree could alter the properties of the food significantly and lead to different swallowing physiology as compared to puree. The current study investigated the differences between traditional and molded puree in terms of swallowing physiology and perception in healthy individuals. Thirty two participants were included. Two outcomes were used to quantify the oral preparatory and oral phase. Fibreoptic endoscopic evaluation of swallowing was used to assess the pharyngeal phase as it could retain the purees in their original form. Six outcomes were collected. Perceptual rating of the purees were provided by participants in six domains. Molded puree required significantly more masticatory cycles (p < 0.001) and longer time for ingestion (p < 0.001). Molded puree had longer swallow reaction time (p = 0.001) and more inferior site of swallow initiation (p = 0.007) compared with traditional puree. Participants' satisfaction with the appearance, texture and overall of molded puree was significantly greater. Molded puree was perceived to be more difficult to chew and swallow. This study established that the two types of puree were different in various aspects. The study also provided important clinical implications regarding the use of molded puree as a form of texture modified diet (TMD) in patients with dysphagia. The results could serve as the foundation of larger cohort studies on the effect of various TMDs on patients with dysphagia.
浓汤通常开给有咀嚼和团块形成困难的患者,但它的外观可能会对食欲和摄入量产生负面影响。成型的浓汤是作为传统浓汤的替代品推向市场的,但浓汤的成型过程可能会显著改变食物的特性,并导致与浓汤相比不同的吞咽生理。目前的研究调查了健康个体中传统浓汤和成型浓汤在吞咽生理和感知方面的差异。共纳入 32 名参与者。使用两种结果来量化口腔准备期和口腔期。纤维内镜吞咽评估用于评估咽部期,因为它可以保持浓汤的原始形态。共收集了 6 项结果。参与者在 6 个领域对浓汤进行了感知评分。成型浓汤需要更多的咀嚼周期(p<0.001)和更长的吞咽时间(p<0.001)。与传统浓汤相比,成型浓汤的吞咽反应时间更长(p=0.001),吞咽起始部位更低(p=0.007)。参与者对成型浓汤的外观、质地和整体满意度明显更高。成型浓汤被认为更难咀嚼和吞咽。这项研究表明,两种浓汤在各个方面都存在差异。该研究还为在吞咽困难患者中使用成型浓汤作为质地改良饮食(TMD)提供了重要的临床意义。研究结果可以为更大的关于各种 TMD 对吞咽困难患者影响的队列研究提供基础。