Diniz Sara Elisa, Vale João, Fonte Hélder, Xará-Leite Francisco, Barros Luís Henrique, Claro Rui
Department of Orthopaedics, Centro Hospitalar Universitário do Porto-Hospital de Santo António, Porto, Portugal.
Department of Orthopedics, Shoulder Unit, Centro Hospitalar Universitário do Porto, Porto, Portugal.
J Orthop Case Rep. 2022 Oct;12(10):91-96. doi: 10.13107/jocr.2022.v12.i10.3382.
Chronic shoulder dislocations are infrequent and can be easily overlooked unless a carefully clinical history, physical examination, and radiographic evaluation are undertaken. Bilateral simultaneous instability is almost pathognomonic for a convulsive disorder. To the best of our knowledge, we describe the first case of asymmetric bilateral chronic dislocation.
A 34-year-old male patient with a history of epilepsy and schizophrenia and multiple seizure episodes, suffered a bilateral asymmetric shoulder dislocation. Radiological examination revealed a posterior shoulder dislocation of the right shoulder with a severe reverse Hill-Sachs lesion comprising more than 50% of the humeral head surface, while on the left shoulder, a chronic anterior shoulder dislocation with a Hill-Sachs lesion of moderate dimension. On the right shoulder, a hemiarthroplasty was performed, and on the left, a stabilization with Remplissage Technique, subscapularis plication, and temporary trans-articular Steinmann pin fixation was done. After bilateral rehabilitation, the patient showed residual pain in the left shoulder and slight range of motion limitation. There were no new episodes of shoulder instability.
Our aim is to emphasize the importance of being alert to flag patients and make a prompt and accurate diagnosis of acute shoulder instability episodes, to avoid unnecessary morbidity, as well as of a high index of suspicion when a history of seizures is present. Despite the uncertain prognosis of a bilateral chronic shoulder dislocation functional results, the surgeon must take into consideration the patient's age, functional demand, and expectations to define the best treatment strategy.
慢性肩关节脱位并不常见,除非进行仔细的临床病史询问、体格检查和影像学评估,否则很容易被忽视。双侧同时不稳定几乎是惊厥性疾病的特征性表现。据我们所知,我们描述了首例不对称双侧慢性脱位病例。
一名34岁男性患者,有癫痫和精神分裂症病史且多次发作,双侧肩关节不对称脱位。影像学检查显示,右肩为后脱位,伴有严重的反Hill-Sachs损伤,累及肱骨头表面超过50%,而左肩为慢性前脱位,伴有中等大小的Hill-Sachs损伤。右侧行半关节置换术,左侧采用Remplissage技术、肩胛下肌折叠术和临时经关节斯氏针固定进行稳定治疗。双侧康复后,患者左肩仍有残留疼痛,活动范围略有受限。未出现新的肩关节不稳定发作。
我们的目的是强调警惕标记患者并对急性肩关节不稳定发作做出迅速准确诊断的重要性,以避免不必要的发病率,以及在有癫痫发作史时保持高度怀疑指数。尽管双侧慢性肩关节脱位的功能结果预后不确定,但外科医生必须考虑患者的年龄、功能需求和期望,以确定最佳治疗策略。