Department of Comparative Biomedicine and Food Science, University of Padova, Legnaro, Padova, Italy.
Ethics Laboratory for Veterinary Medicine, Conservation, and Animal Welfare, University of Padova, Legnaro, Padova, Italy.
PLoS One. 2023 Mar 6;18(3):e0282507. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0282507. eCollection 2023.
South Africa's wide range of animal facilities offers many different types of Animal-Visitor Interactions, wild animal encounters where animals and visitors come closer than in normal circumstances. The aim of this study was to provide a map of the ethically relevant aspects involved in AVIs in South Africa as a first step towards regulating these activities. A participative approach based on the ethical matrix, a tool which organizes the ethical standings of the stakeholders by three bearing ethical principles (wellbeing, autonomy, fairness), was applied. The matrix was populated through a top-down approach and refined by engaging stakeholders in a workshop and two online self-administrated surveys. The outcome is a map of the value demands concerning Animal Visitor Interactions. This map shows how the ethical acceptability of AVIs is linked to different relevant issues like animal welfare, education, biodiversity conservation, sustainability, human competency, facility mission, impact on scientific research and socio-economic outcomes. In addition, results highlighted the importance of cooperation among stakeholders and suggested that attention for animal welfare can inform decision making and inspire a multidisciplinary approach in implementing a regulatory frame for South African wildlife facilities.
南非拥有广泛的动物设施,提供了许多不同类型的动物访客互动,这些互动让动物和访客比在正常情况下更接近。本研究的目的是提供南非动物访客互动中涉及的伦理相关方面的图谱,作为监管这些活动的第一步。本研究采用了一种基于伦理矩阵的参与式方法,该工具通过三个伦理原则(福祉、自主、公平)来组织利益相关者的立场。通过自上而下的方法填充矩阵,并通过研讨会和两次在线自我管理调查让利益相关者参与来进行完善。结果是一张关于动物访客互动的价值需求图谱。该图谱显示了动物访客互动的伦理可接受性如何与不同的相关问题相关联,如动物福利、教育、生物多样性保护、可持续性、人类能力、设施使命、对科学研究的影响和社会经济成果。此外,结果还强调了利益相关者之间合作的重要性,并表明对动物福利的关注可以为决策提供信息,并为实施南非野生动物设施的监管框架提供多学科方法。