NIHR Academic Clinical Fellow in Special Care Dentistry, Eastman Dental Institute, University College London, UK.
Cardiff Unit for Research and Evaluation in Medical and Dental Education, School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University, UK.
Br Dent J. 2023 Mar;234(5):329-333. doi: 10.1038/s41415-023-5572-8. Epub 2023 Mar 10.
Introduction In the UK, the General Dental Council specifies nine principles of professional standards that dental registrants must follow. There are views that such standards are high, patients' expectations are rising, and the professionalism of dental professionals is increasingly scrutinised. This paper explores whether the high standards expected in dentistry are justified.Methods We applied thematic analysis to 772 free-text responses from dental team members and the public to a modified Delphi survey. Respondents described their views of professional and unprofessional behaviours in dentistry. Data were obtained as part of a larger review of professionalism in dentistry.Results Two lines of argument were identified: professionalism standards are high, but justifiably so; and professionalism standards are too high. Within these, four broad themes emerged: patient trust; comparison with other professions; a culture of fear; and perfection.Conclusion High professionalism standards are justified in a profession where patient trust is paramount. However, a problem lies in the culture that surrounds professionalism in terms of litigation and dental professionals feel pressure to possess an unattainable, infallible nature. These negative impacts need minimising. We suggest that undergraduates and continuing professional development approach professionalism with care, to foster a supportive, positive and reflective culture of professionalism.
引言
在英国,英国牙科注册管理局规定了牙科注册医生必须遵守的九条专业标准原则。有人认为这些标准很高,患者的期望在不断提高,牙科医生的专业水平也越来越受到关注。本文探讨了在牙科领域中,高标准是否合理。
方法
我们对 772 名牙科团队成员和公众对一项经修改的德尔菲调查的自由文本回复进行了主题分析。受访者描述了他们对牙科领域中专业和不专业行为的看法。这些数据是作为对牙科专业精神的更大范围审查的一部分获得的。
结果
专业标准很高,但合理;以及专业标准过高。在这两种论点中,出现了四个广泛的主题:患者信任;与其他专业的比较;恐惧文化;以及完美主义。
结论
在一个患者信任至关重要的行业中,高标准的专业精神是合理的。然而,问题在于围绕专业精神的文化,例如诉讼,以及牙科医生感到有压力要拥有一种难以达到的、完美无缺的特质。这些负面影响需要最小化。我们建议本科生和继续教育应以谨慎的态度对待专业精神,培养一种支持性、积极和反思性的专业精神文化。