Chen Meizhong, Zhang Yong, Zhang Wei, Huang Shufen, Zhu Shuangli, Li Caixia, Guo Xue, Zeng Hanri, Fang Ling, Ke Bixia, Li Hui, Yoshida Hiromu, Xu Wenbo, Ke Changwen, Deng Xiaoling, Zheng Huanying
Guangdong Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Guangdong Workstation for Emerging Infectious Disease Control and Prevention, Guangzhou, China.
School of Public Health, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, China.
J Med Virol. 2023 Mar;95(3):e28668. doi: 10.1002/jmv.28668.
Polio cases can be missed by acute flaccid paralysis (AFP) case surveillance alone, emphasizing the importance of environmental surveillance (ES). In this study, to investigate the serotype distribution and epidemiological trends of poliovirus (PV), we characterized PV isolated from domestic sewage in Guangzhou City, Guangdong Province, China from 2009 to 2021. A total of 624 sewage samples were collected from the Liede Sewage Treatment Plant, and the positive rates of PV and non-polio enteroviruses were 66.67% (416/624) and 78.37% (489/624), respectively. After sewage sample treatment, each sewage sample was inoculated in six replicate tubes of three cell lines, and 3370 viruses were isolated during the 13-year surveillance period. Among these, 1086 isolates were identified as PV, including type 1 PV (21.36%), type 2 PV (29.19%), and type 3 PV (49.48%). Based on VP1 sequences, 1057 strains were identified as Sabin-like, 21 strains were high-mutant vaccines, and eight strains were vaccine-derived poliovirus (VDPV). The numbers and serotypes of PV isolates in sewage were influenced by the vaccine switch strategy. After type 2 OPV was removed from the trivalent oral PV (OPV) vaccine and a bivalent OPV (bOPV) was adopted in May 2016, the last type 2 PV strain was isolated from sewage, with no detection thereafter. Type 3 PV isolates increased significantly and became the dominant serotype. Before and after the second vaccine switch in January 2020, that is, from the first dose of IPV and second-fourth doses of bOPV to the first two doses of IPV and third-fourth doses of bOPV, there was also a statistical difference in PV positivity rates in sewage samples. Seven type 2 VDPVs and one type 3 VDPV were identified in sewage samples in 2009-2021, and phylogenetic analysis indicated that all VDPVs isolated from ES in Guangdong are newly discovered VDPVs, different from VDPV previously discovered in China, and were classified as ambiguous VDPV. It is noteworthy that no VDPV cases were reported in AFP case surveillance in the same period. In conclusion, continued PV ES in Guangzhou since April 2008 has been a useful supplement to AFP case surveillance, providing an important basis for evaluating the effectiveness of vaccine immunization strategies. ES improves early detection, prevention, and control; accordingly, this strategy can curb the circulation of VDPVs and provide a strong laboratory basis for maintaining a polio-free status.
仅通过急性弛缓性麻痹(AFP)病例监测可能会漏报脊髓灰质炎病例,这凸显了环境监测(ES)的重要性。在本研究中,为调查脊髓灰质炎病毒(PV)的血清型分布和流行病学趋势,我们对2009年至2021年从中国广东省广州市生活污水中分离出的PV进行了特征分析。从猎德污水处理厂共采集了624份污水样本,PV和非脊髓灰质炎肠道病毒的阳性率分别为66.67%(416/624)和78.37%(489/624)。对污水样本进行处理后,将每个污水样本接种到三种细胞系的六个重复管中,在13年的监测期内分离出3370株病毒。其中,1086株分离株被鉴定为PV,包括1型PV(21.36%)、2型PV(29.19%)和3型PV(49.48%)。基于VP1序列,1057株被鉴定为Sabin样毒株,21株为高突变疫苗株,8株为疫苗衍生脊髓灰质炎病毒(VDPV)。污水中PV分离株的数量和血清型受疫苗转换策略的影响。2016年5月,三价口服PV(OPV)疫苗中去除2型OPV并采用二价OPV(bOPV)后,最后一株2型PV毒株从污水中分离出来,此后未再检测到。3型PV分离株显著增加并成为优势血清型。2020年1月第二次疫苗转换前后,即从第一剂灭活脊髓灰质炎疫苗(IPV)和第二至第四剂bOPV转换为前两剂IPV和第三至第四剂bOPV,污水样本中PV阳性率也存在统计学差异。2009年至2021年在污水样本中鉴定出7株2型VDPV和1株3型VDPV,系统发育分析表明,从广东环境监测中分离出的所有VDPV都是新发现的VDPV,与中国此前发现的VDPV不同,被归类为模糊VDPV。值得注意的是,同期AFP病例监测中未报告VDPV病例。总之,自2008年4月以来在广州持续开展的PV环境监测是AFP病例监测的有益补充,为评估疫苗免疫策略的有效性提供了重要依据。环境监测改善了早期发现、预防和控制;因此,该策略可以遏制VDPV的传播,并为维持无脊髓灰质炎状态提供有力的实验室依据。