1Equity and Justice in Neurosurgery, Durham.
2Department of Neurosurgery, Duke University, Durham.
J Neurosurg. 2023 Mar 10;139(4):1101-1108. doi: 10.3171/2023.1.JNS221743. Print 2023 Oct 1.
The rates of women and underrepresented racial and ethnic minority (UREM) students successfully matching into neurosurgical residency are extremely low and do not reflect the makeup of the general population. As of 2019, only 17.5% of neurosurgical residents in the United States were women, 4.95% were Black or African American, and 7.2% were Hispanic or Latinx. Earlier recruitment of UREM students will help to diversify the neurosurgical workforce. Therefore, the authors developed a virtual educational event for undergraduate students entitled "Future Leaders in Neurosurgery Symposium for Underrepresented Students'' (FLNSUS). The primary objectives of the FLNSUS were to expose attendees to 1) neurosurgeons from diverse gender, racial, and ethnic backgrounds; 2) neurosurgical research; 3) opportunities for neurosurgical mentorship; and 4) information about life as a neurosurgeon. The authors hypothesized that the FLNSUS would increase student self-confidence, provide exposure to the specialty, and reduce perceived barriers to a neurosurgical career.
To measure the change in participant perceptions of neurosurgery, pre- and postsymposium surveys were administered to attendees. Of the 269 participants who completed the presymposium survey, 250 participated in the virtual event and 124 completed the postsymposium survey. Paired pre- and postsurvey responses were used for analysis, yielding a response rate of 46%. To assess the impact of participant perceptions of neurosurgery as a field, pre- and postsurvey responses to questions were compared. The change in response was analyzed, and a nonparametric sign test was performed to check for significant differences.
According to the sign test, applicants showed increased familiarity with the field (p < 0.001), increased confidence in their abilities to become neurosurgeons (p = 0.014), and increased exposure to neurosurgeons from diverse gender, racial, and ethnic backgrounds (p < 0.001 for all categories).
These results reflect a significant improvement in student perceptions of neurosurgery and suggest that symposiums like the FLNSUS may promote further diversification of the field. The authors anticipate that events promoting diversity in neurosurgery will lead to a more equitable workforce that will ultimately translate to enhanced research productivity, cultural humility, and patient-centered care in neurosurgery.
在美国,成功进入神经外科住院医师培训的女性和代表性不足的少数族裔(UREM)学生的比例极低,这与一般人群的构成情况并不相符。截至 2019 年,美国仅有 17.5%的神经外科住院医师为女性,4.95%为非裔美国人,7.2%为西班牙裔或拉丁裔。因此,更早地招募 UREM 学生将有助于神经外科领域的多元化。为此,作者为本科生开发了一项名为“代表性不足学生神经外科学未来领袖研讨会”(FLNSUS)的虚拟教育活动。FLNSUS 的主要目标是让参与者接触到 1)来自不同性别、种族和族裔背景的神经外科医生;2)神经外科研究;3)神经外科导师机会;以及 4)神经外科医生生活的相关信息。作者假设,FLNSUS 将提高学生的自信心,使他们对该专业有更多的了解,并减少对神经外科职业的认知障碍。
为了衡量参与者对神经外科的看法的变化,在研讨会前后向参与者发放了调查问卷。在完成前测调查问卷的 269 名参与者中,有 250 人参加了虚拟活动,其中 124 人完成了后测调查问卷。使用前后测调查问卷的配对回答进行分析,得出的应答率为 46%。为了评估参与者对神经外科领域看法的变化,比较了前后测调查问卷中对相关问题的回答。分析了回答的变化,并进行了非参数符号检验以检查是否存在显著差异。
根据符号检验,申请人对该领域的熟悉程度有所提高(p<0.001),对自己成为神经外科医生的能力更有信心(p=0.014),并且对来自不同性别、种族和族裔背景的神经外科医生的了解也有所增加(所有类别的 p<0.001)。
这些结果反映了学生对神经外科的看法有了显著改善,表明像 FLNSUS 这样的研讨会可能会促进该领域的进一步多元化。作者预计,促进神经外科多样性的活动将导致更公平的劳动力,最终转化为神经外科领域的研究生产力提高、文化谦逊和以患者为中心的护理。