Pilný J, Kachlík D, Zeman P, Horáčková K, Hájek P
Ortopedické oddělení, Nemocnice Nové Město na Moravě.
Univerzita Karlova, Lékařská fakulta v Hradci Králové, Ústav anatomie, Hradec Králové.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2023;90(1):29-33.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Carpometacarpal (CMC) instabilities of the thumb joint occur after injuries or due to joint overload in patients with congenital joint hypermobility. They are often undiagnosed and, if left untreated, are the basis for the development of rhizarthrosis in young individuals. The authors present the results of the Eaton-Littler technique. MATERIAL AND METHODS The authors present a set of 53 CMC joints of patients with an average age of 26.8 years (15-43 years) operated on in the years 2005-2017. Post-traumatic conditions were found in 10 patients and in 43 cases instability was caused by hyperlaxity, also demonstrated in other joints. The operation was performed from the Wagner's modified anteroradial approach. After the operation, a plaster splint was applied for 6 weeks, after which rehabilitation (magnetotherapy, warm-up) began. Patients were evaluated using the VAS (pain at rest and during exercise), DASH score in the work module, and subjective evaluation (no difficulties, difficulties not limiting normal activities, and difficulties limiting normal activities) before surgery and 36 months after surgery. RESULTS During the preoperative assessment, the average VAS value was 5.6 at rest and 8.3 during exercise. During the VAS assessment at rest, the values at 6, 12, 24 and 36 months after surgery were 5.6, 2.9, 0.9, 1, 2 and 1.1. When evaluated in the given intervals under load, the detected values were 4.1, 2, 2.2 and 2.4. The DASH score in the work module was 81.2 before surgery, 46.3 at 6 months, 15.2 at 12 months, 17.3 at 24 months, and 18.4 at 36 months after surgery. In the subjective self-assessment made at 36 months after surgery, 39 patients (74%) assessed their condition as having no difficulties, ten patients (19%) reported difficulties that did not limit normal activities, and four patients (7%) reported difficulties limiting normal activities. DISCUSSION Most authors present the results of their surgeries in patients with post-traumatic joint instability, and they report excellent results at two to six years after surgery. There is a negligible number of studies addressing instabilities in patients with instability caused by hypermobility. When using the conventional method described by the authors in 1973, our results of the evaluation performed at 36 months after surgery are comparable to those reported by other authors. We are well aware of the fact that this is a short-term follow-up and that this method does not prevent developing degenerative changes in the case of long-term follow-up, but reduces clinical difficulties and may delay the development of severe rhizarthrosis in young individuals. CONCLUSIONS CMC instability of the thumb joint is a relatively common disorder, although not all individuals experience clinical difficulties. In the case of difficulties, the instability needs to be diagnosed and treated as this is how the development of early rhizarthrosis in the predisposed individuals can be prevented. Our conclusions suggest a possibility of a surgical solution with good results. Key words: carpometacarpal thumb joint, thumb CMC joint, carpometacarpal thumb instability, joint laxity, rhizarthrosis.
研究目的 拇指关节的腕掌(CMC)不稳定发生于损伤后或先天性关节活动过度患者的关节负荷过重时。它们常常未被诊断出来,若不治疗,是年轻人发生拇指关节病的基础。作者介绍了伊顿-利特勒技术的结果。
材料与方法 作者展示了一组2005年至2017年接受手术的患者的53个CMC关节,患者平均年龄26.8岁(15 - 43岁)。10例患者存在创伤后情况,43例不稳定是由关节过度松弛引起的,其他关节也有这种情况。手术采用瓦格纳改良的桡前入路。术后应用石膏夹板6周,之后开始康复治疗(磁疗、热身)。在手术前及术后36个月,使用视觉模拟评分法(VAS,静息及运动时疼痛)、工作模块中的DASH评分以及主观评估(无困难、困难但不限制正常活动、困难限制正常活动)对患者进行评估。
结果 术前评估时,静息时VAS平均评分为5.6,运动时为8.3。术后6、12、24和36个月静息时VAS评估值分别为5.6、2.9、0.9、1.2和1.1。在给定负荷时间段评估时,检测值分别为4.1、2、2.2和2.4。工作模块中的DASH评分术前为81.2,术后6个月为46.3,12个月为15.2,24个月为17.3,36个月为18.4。术后36个月主观自我评估中,39例患者(74%)评估自身状况无困难,10例患者(19%)报告有困难但不限制正常活动,4例患者(7%)报告有困难限制正常活动。
讨论 大多数作者展示了他们对创伤后关节不稳定患者手术的结果,且报告术后两到六年效果良好。针对由关节活动过度引起不稳定的患者的不稳定情况进行研究的数量极少。当使用作者1973年描述的传统方法时,我们术后36个月的评估结果与其他作者报告的结果相当。我们清楚这是短期随访,且该方法在长期随访中不能防止退行性改变的发生,但可减少临床困难,并可能延缓年轻人严重拇指关节病的发展。
结论 拇指关节的CMC不稳定是一种相对常见的病症,尽管并非所有个体都有临床困难。出现困难时,需对不稳定进行诊断和治疗,因为这样可预防易感个体早期拇指关节病的发展。我们的结论表明手术解决方法有可能取得良好效果。
拇指腕掌关节;拇指CMC关节;拇指腕掌关节不稳定;关节松弛;拇指关节病