Institute of Humanities and Social Sciences, Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, China.
School of Health Management, Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, China.
Front Public Health. 2023 Feb 24;11:1087358. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1087358. eCollection 2023.
Machine learning (ML) algorithms, as an early branch of artificial intelligence technology, can effectively simulate human behavior by training on data from the training set. Machine learning algorithms were used in this study to predict patient choice tendencies in medical decision-making. Its goal was to help physicians understand patient preferences and to serve as a resource for the development of decision-making schemes in clinical treatment. As a result, physicians and patients can have better conversations at lower expenses, leading to better medical decisions.
Patient medical decision-making tendencies were predicted by primary survey data obtained from 248 participants at third-level grade-A hospitals in China. Specifically, 12 predictor variables were set according to the literature review, and four types of outcome variables were set based on the optimization principle of clinical diagnosis and treatment. That is, the patient's medical decision-making tendency, which is classified as treatment effect, treatment cost, treatment side effect, and treatment experience. In conjunction with the study's data characteristics, three ML classification algorithms, decision tree (DT), k-nearest neighbor (KNN), and support vector machine (SVM), were used to predict patients' medical decision-making tendency, and the performance of the three types of algorithms was compared.
The accuracy of the DT algorithm for predicting patients' choice tendency in medical decision making is 80% for treatment effect, 60% for treatment cost, 56% for treatment side effects, and 60% for treatment experience, followed by the KNN algorithm at 78%, 66%, 74%, 84%, and the SVM algorithm at 82%, 76%, 80%, 94%. At the same time, the comprehensive evaluation index F1-score of the DT algorithm are 0.80, 0.61, 0.58, 0.60, the KNN algorithm are 0.75, 0.65, 0.71, 0.84, and the SVM algorithm are 0.81, 0.74, 0.73, 0.94.
Among the three ML classification algorithms, SVM has the highest accuracy and the best performance. Therefore, the prediction results have certain reference values and guiding significance for physicians to formulate clinical treatment plans. The research results are helpful to promote the development and application of a patient-centered medical decision assistance system, to resolve the conflict of interests between physicians and patients and assist them to realize scientific decision-making.
机器学习(ML)算法作为人工智能技术的早期分支,可以通过在训练集中的数据进行训练,有效地模拟人类行为。本研究使用机器学习算法预测医学决策中的患者选择倾向。其目的是帮助医生了解患者的偏好,并为临床治疗决策方案的制定提供资源。这样,医生和患者可以以更低的成本进行更好的沟通,从而做出更好的医疗决策。
通过在中国三级甲等医院的 248 名参与者的初步调查数据预测患者的医疗决策倾向。具体来说,根据文献综述设置了 12 个预测变量,并根据临床诊断和治疗的优化原则设置了四种类型的结果变量。即患者的医疗决策倾向,分为治疗效果、治疗成本、治疗副作用和治疗体验。结合研究数据的特点,采用决策树(DT)、k-近邻(KNN)和支持向量机(SVM)三种 ML 分类算法预测患者的医疗决策倾向,并比较了三种算法的性能。
DT 算法预测患者医疗决策倾向的准确率分别为治疗效果 80%、治疗成本 60%、治疗副作用 56%、治疗体验 60%,其次是 KNN 算法的 78%、66%、74%、84%,SVM 算法的 82%、76%、80%、94%。同时,DT 算法的综合评价指标 F1-score 分别为 0.80、0.61、0.58、0.60,KNN 算法的分别为 0.75、0.65、0.71、0.84,SVM 算法的分别为 0.81、0.74、0.73、0.94。
在三种 ML 分类算法中,SVM 的准确率最高,性能最好。因此,预测结果对医生制定临床治疗方案具有一定的参考价值和指导意义。研究结果有助于促进以患者为中心的医疗决策辅助系统的发展和应用,解决医患利益冲突,帮助他们做出科学决策。