Woroniecki Robert, Moritz Michael L
Stony Brook Children's, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY, United States.
UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA, United States.
Front Pediatr. 2023 Feb 23;11:1104628. doi: 10.3389/fped.2023.1104628. eCollection 2023.
Human spirit is an integral part of the medicinal art and science trifecta: body-mind-spirit, and it is contained in the World Health Organization definition of health. Human spirit is defined as our purpose in life, relationships with all living creatures or "Higher Power", and in general our place on planet Earth. Spirituality is a required part of patient care according to Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations. There is an abundant medical literature that documents discrepancies in the results between studies and populations, and points to the importance of cultural, ethnic, spiritual or religious differences. Validated questionnaires used in research for last several decades demonstrated an association of spirituality with clinical outcomes, coping, and quality of life in different adult chronic diseases. There are also validated scales to measure hope in children based on the premise that children are goal directed and that their goal-related thoughts can be understood, yet their purposefulness, meaning of life and spirit in pediatric nephrology remains mostly unexamined. Although pediatric nephrology has made significant advances in molecular techniques, artificial intelligence, machine learning, and started to address more broad social issues such as racism, health equity, diversity of our work force, etc, it lacks both systematic ways of studying and philosophical approach to fostering human spirit. This mini review examines the place and knowledge gaps in human spirit and spirituality in pediatric nephrology. We review the concept of the human spirit and medical literature pertaining to its role in pediatric nephrology.
人类精神是医学艺术与科学三元组(身体 - 心理 - 精神)中不可或缺的一部分,它包含在世界卫生组织对健康的定义之中。人类精神被定义为我们的生活目标、与所有生物或“更高力量”的关系,以及总体而言我们在地球上的位置。根据医疗保健组织认证联合委员会的规定,精神层面是患者护理的必要组成部分。有大量医学文献记录了不同研究与人群之间结果的差异,并指出文化、种族、精神或宗教差异的重要性。在过去几十年的研究中使用的经过验证的问卷表明,精神层面与不同成人慢性病的临床结果、应对方式及生活质量相关。也有经过验证的量表用于测量儿童的希望,其前提是儿童有目标导向,且他们与目标相关的想法是可以理解的,然而在儿科肾脏病学中,他们的目的性、生命意义和精神层面大多仍未得到研究。尽管儿科肾脏病学在分子技术、人工智能、机器学习方面取得了重大进展,并开始解决更广泛的社会问题,如种族主义、健康公平、劳动力多样性等,但它缺乏研究人类精神的系统方法和培养人类精神的哲学方法。本综述探讨了儿科肾脏病学中人类精神和灵性的地位及知识空白。我们回顾了人类精神的概念以及与其在儿科肾脏病学中作用相关的医学文献。