Jo Jason J, Cheng Christopher P, Ying Stephanie, Chelnis James G
Department of Medical Education, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY 10029, USA.
Manhattan Face and Eye, New York, NY 10019, USA.
J Ophthalmol. 2023 Mar 8;2023:4762460. doi: 10.1155/2023/4762460. eCollection 2023.
The presence and influence of physician review websites (PRW) have increased significantly in the field of medicine. This study aims to better understand determinants of patient satisfaction and the sentiment of ophthalmologists using natural language processing of Healthgrades reviews.
Healthgrades is a PRW where patients submit verified reviews, containing a star rating and a narrative review, of US-based ophthalmologists. This was a quantitative observational study conducted on May 23, 2022. We identified associations between physician demographics and both the sentiment analysis scores of narrative reviews and star ratings using the Student's -tests and one-way ANOVA tests. After natural language processing the reviews, a logistic regression explored the impacts of the most frequent words on the positivity of a given review.
This study examined a total of 16700 reviews of 1125 ophthalmologists. Ophthalmologists of younger age and male gender received statistically significantly higher star ratings and sentiment analysis scores; analysis of location of practice did not affect scores. Textual analysis revealed that words describing the physician's personality, such as "friendly" and "caring," increased the likelihood of reviews being positive more than descriptors of the visit's effectiveness, such as "results" and "efficient."
Younger and male ophthalmologists received higher star ratings and sentiment analysis scores. Additionally, results indicated that words describing the ophthalmologist's pleasant personality and the visit's effectiveness most positively impacted a review, whereas descriptors of a wait or an unpleasant personality most negatively impacted a review.
医生评价网站(PRW)在医学领域的存在和影响力显著增加。本研究旨在通过对Healthgrades评价进行自然语言处理,更好地了解患者满意度的决定因素以及眼科医生的情感倾向。
Healthgrades是一个PRW,患者在上面提交对美国眼科医生的经过验证的评价,包括星级评分和叙述性评价。这是一项于2022年5月23日进行的定量观察性研究。我们使用学生t检验和单因素方差分析测试,确定医生人口统计学特征与叙述性评价的情感分析得分以及星级评分之间的关联。在对评价进行自然语言处理后,逻辑回归探索了最频繁出现的词汇对给定评价积极性的影响。
本研究共检查了1125名眼科医生的16700条评价。年龄较小的男性眼科医生在统计学上获得了显著更高的星级评分和情感分析得分;对执业地点的分析并未影响得分。文本分析表明,描述医生个性的词汇,如“友好”和“体贴”,比描述就诊效果的词汇,如“结果”和“高效”,更能增加评价为积极的可能性。
年轻和男性眼科医生获得了更高的星级评分和情感分析得分。此外,结果表明,描述眼科医生令人愉悦的个性和就诊效果的词汇对评价的积极影响最大,而描述等待或不愉快个性的词汇对评价的负面影响最大。