The National Food Institute, Technical University of Denmark, Lyngby, Denmark.
Prev Vet Med. 2023 May;214:105899. doi: 10.1016/j.prevetmed.2023.105899. Epub 2023 Mar 10.
Research has long established the connection between antimicrobial use (AMU) and antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in production animals, and shown that the ceasing of AMU reduces AMR. Our previous study of Danish slaughter-pig production found a quantitative relationship between lifetime AMU and abundance of antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs). This study aimed to generate further quantitative knowledge on how changes in AMU in farms influence the abundance of ARGs both with immediate effect and over time. The study included 83 farms that were visited from 1 to 5 times. From each visit, a pooled faecal sample was produced. The abundance of ARGs was obtained by metagenomics. We used two-level linear mixed models for estimating the effect of AMU on the abundance of ARGs against six antimicrobial classes. The lifetime AMU of each batch was calculated from usage during their three rearing periods; as piglets, weaners and slaughter pigs (rearing pathway). AMU at farm level was estimated as the mean lifetime AMU of the sampled batches from each farm. At batch level, AMU was measured as the deviation between the batch-specific lifetime AMU and the general mean lifetime AMU at the farm. For peroral tetracycline and macrolide use there was a significant quantitative linear effect on the abundance of ARGs in batches within individual farms, indicating an immediate effect of changed AMU from batch to batch within farms. These estimated effects between batches within farms were approximately 1/2-1/3 of the effect estimated between farms. For all antimicrobial classes, the effect of the mean farm-level AMU and the abundance of ARGs present in the faeces of slaughter pigs was significant. This effect was identified only for peroral use, except for lincosamides, where the effect was for parenteral use. The results also indicated that the abundance of ARGs against a specific antimicrobial class also increased by the peroral usage of one or several other antimicrobial classes, except for ARGs against beta-lactams. These effects were generally lower than the AMU effect of the specific antimicrobial class. Overall, the farm peroral mean lifetime AMU affected the abundance of ARGs at antimicrobial class level and abundance of ARGs of other classes. However, the difference of AMU of the slaughter-pig batches affected only the abundance of ARGs at the same antimicrobial class level in the same antimicrobial class. The results do not exclude that parenteral usage of antimicrobials may have an effect on the abundance of ARGs.
研究早就证实了生产动物中抗菌药物使用(AMU)与抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)之间的联系,并表明停止 AMU 可降低 AMR。我们之前对丹麦屠宰猪生产的研究发现,一生中 AMU 与抗菌药物耐药基因(ARGs)的丰度之间存在定量关系。本研究旨在进一步定量了解农场中 AMU 的变化如何对 ARGs 的丰度产生即时和长期影响。该研究包括 83 个农场,这些农场在 1 到 5 次访问中被访问。每次访问时,都会采集一组粪便样本。通过宏基因组学获得 ARGs 的丰度。我们使用两层线性混合模型来估计 AMU 对六种抗菌药物类别中 ARGs 丰度的影响。每个批次的终生 AMU 是根据其三个育肥期(仔猪、断奶仔猪和育肥猪(育肥途径))期间的使用情况计算得出的。农场层面的 AMU 是通过从每个农场采集的样本批次的平均终生 AMU 来估计的。在批次层面,AMU 是通过批次特异性终生 AMU 与农场的一般平均终生 AMU 之间的偏差来测量的。对于口服四环素和大环内酯类药物的使用,个体农场内的批次中存在 ARGs 丰度的定量线性影响,表明农场内批次之间 AMU 的变化具有即时影响。这些在农场内批次之间的估计效应大约是在农场之间估计的效应的 1/2-1/3。对于所有抗菌药物类别,农场层面平均 AMU 以及屠宰猪粪便中存在的 ARGs 丰度均与 ARGs 丰度显著相关。除了林可酰胺类药物外,这种影响仅存在于口服使用中,林可酰胺类药物的影响是针对注射使用的。结果还表明,除了β-内酰胺类药物外,针对特定抗菌药物类别的 ARGs 丰度也会因其他一种或几种抗菌药物类别的口服使用而增加。这些效应通常低于特定抗菌药物类别的 AMU 效应。总体而言,农场口服平均终生 AMU 影响抗菌药物类别水平的 ARGs 丰度和其他类别 ARGs 的丰度。然而,仅屠宰猪批次的 AMU 差异会影响相同抗菌药物类别水平上相同抗菌药物类别的 ARGs 丰度。结果并不排除注射使用抗菌药物可能会对抗菌药物耐药基因丰度产生影响。