Chen Chong, Tassou Adrien, Morales Valentina, Scherrer Grégory
bioRxiv. 2023 Mar 15:2023.03.08.531580. doi: 10.1101/2023.03.08.531580.
The neural substrate of pain experience has been described as a dense network of connected brain regions. However, the connectivity pattern of these brain regions remains elusive, precluding a deeper understanding of how pain emerges from the structural connectivity. Here, we use graph theory to systematically characterize the architecture of a comprehensive pain network, including both cortical and subcortical brain areas. This structural brain network consists of 49 nodes denoting pain-related brain areas, linked by edges representing their relative incoming and outgoing axonal projection strengths. Sixty-three percent of brain areas in this structural pain network share reciprocal connections, reflecting a dense network. The clustering coefficient, a measurement of the probability that adjacent nodes are connected, indicates that brain areas in the pain network tend to cluster together. Community detection, the process of discovering cohesive groups in complex networks, successfully reveals two known subnetworks that specifically mediate the sensory and affective components of pain, respectively. Assortativity analysis, which evaluates the tendency of nodes to connect with other nodes with similar features, indicates that the pain network is assortative. Finally, robustness, the resistance of a complex network to failures and perturbations, indicates that the pain network displays a high degree of error tolerance (local failure rarely affects the global information carried by the network) but is vulnerable to attacks (selective removal of hub nodes critically changes network connectivity). Taken together, graph theory analysis unveils an assortative structural pain network in the brain processing nociceptive information, and the vulnerability of this network to attack opens up the possibility of alleviating pain by targeting the most connected brain areas in the network.
疼痛体验的神经基质被描述为一个由相互连接的脑区组成的密集网络。然而,这些脑区的连接模式仍然难以捉摸,这妨碍了我们对疼痛如何从结构连接中产生的更深入理解。在这里,我们使用图论系统地表征一个综合疼痛网络的架构,该网络包括皮层和皮层下脑区。这个结构脑网络由49个表示与疼痛相关脑区的节点组成,通过代表它们相对传入和传出轴突投射强度的边相连。这个结构疼痛网络中63%的脑区存在相互连接,反映出一个密集网络。聚类系数是衡量相邻节点连接概率的指标,它表明疼痛网络中的脑区倾向于聚集在一起。社区检测是在复杂网络中发现凝聚性群组的过程,它成功地揭示了两个分别专门介导疼痛的感觉和情感成分的已知子网络。相关性分析评估节点与具有相似特征的其他节点连接的倾向,结果表明疼痛网络具有相关性。最后,鲁棒性是指复杂网络对故障和扰动的抵抗力,它表明疼痛网络表现出高度的容错性(局部故障很少影响网络携带的全局信息),但容易受到攻击(选择性移除枢纽节点会严重改变网络连接性)。综上所述,图论分析揭示了大脑在处理伤害性信息时存在一个具有相关性的结构疼痛网络,并且这个网络对攻击的脆弱性为通过靶向网络中连接性最强的脑区来缓解疼痛开辟了可能性。