Gariscsak Peter, Gray Gary, Steele Stephen, Elterman D, Doiron R Christopher
School of Medicine, Queen's University, Kingston, ON, Canada.
Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Can Urol Assoc J. 2023 Jun;17(6):E165-E171. doi: 10.5489/cuaj.8176.
An estimated 18% of Canadians have overactive bladder (OAB), with approximately 24% of those reporting difficulty adhering to pharmacotherapy. To date, there has been no investigation into barriers facing sacral neuromodulation (SNM) as treatment for OAB in Canada.
Current Canadian Urological Association members were invited to participate in an anonymous survey. Data collected included open-ended and Likert scale responses addressing barriers to referral for SNM. Qualitative analysis used a Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF), while quantitative responses are reported using descriptive statistics.
A response rate of 20.4% (n=142) was obtained. Most respondents believed SNM was underused (n=82, 57.7%) compared to only 6.3% (n=9) who believed it was used adequately. The most commonly cited reasons for not offering SNM were lack of availability (n=85, 59.9%), expertise (n=49, 34.5%), and funding (n=26, 18.3%). Participants were neutral regarding confidence to appropriately recommend SNM to patients (median 3, interquartile range [IQR] 2-4) and were not confident to manage patient care and issues related to SNM devices (median 2, IQR 1-3). On thematic analysis using the TDF, the most prevalent barriers to SNM care were related to infrastructure and resources. A lack of trained experts and lack of knowledge related to SNM use were also commonly identified barriers.
In this first study exploring urologist-perceived barriers to SNM referral for medically refractory OAB in Canada, urologists acknowledge that SNM implantation is underused but did not feel confident in recommending SNM appropriately. A lack of trained experts and poor funding were also identified as major barriers to SNM referral.
据估计,18%的加拿大人患有膀胱过度活动症(OAB),其中约24%的人报告称难以坚持药物治疗。迄今为止,加拿大尚未对骶神经调节(SNM)作为OAB治疗方法所面临的障碍进行调查。
邀请加拿大泌尿外科学会现任会员参与一项匿名调查。收集的数据包括针对SNM转诊障碍的开放式和李克特量表回答。定性分析采用理论领域框架(TDF),定量回答则使用描述性统计进行报告。
获得了20.4%(n = 142)的回复率。大多数受访者认为与仅6.3%(n = 9)认为其使用充分的受访者相比,SNM未得到充分利用(n = 82,57.7%)。不提供SNM的最常见原因是无法获得(n = 85,59.9%)、专业知识(n = 49,34.5%)和资金(n = 26,18.3%)。参与者对向患者适当推荐SNM的信心处于中性水平(中位数为3,四分位间距[IQR]为2 - 4),并且对管理患者护理以及与SNM设备相关的问题缺乏信心(中位数为2,IQR为1 - 3)。在使用TDF进行的主题分析中,SNM护理最普遍的障碍与基础设施和资源有关。缺乏训练有素的专家以及与SNM使用相关的知识也是常见的障碍。
在这项首次探索加拿大泌尿科医生认为的医学难治性OAB的SNM转诊障碍的研究中,泌尿科医生承认SNM植入未得到充分利用,但对适当推荐SNM缺乏信心。缺乏训练有素的专家和资金不足也被确定为SNM转诊的主要障碍。