Rude Christian I, Tidwell Lane G, Tilton Susan C, Waters Katrina M, Anderson Kim A, Tanguay Robyn L
Department of Environmental and Molecular Toxicology, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR 97331, USA.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Biological Sciences Division, Richland, WA 99354, USA.
Toxics. 2023 Feb 21;11(3):201. doi: 10.3390/toxics11030201.
Passive sampling device (PSD) extracts paired with developmental toxicity assays in (zebrafish) are excellent sensors for whole mixture toxicity associated with the bioavailable non-polar organics at environmental sites. We expand this concept by incorporating RNA-Seq in 48-h post fertilization zebrafish statically exposed to PSD extracts from two Portland Harbor Superfund Site locations: river mile 6.5W (RM 6.5W) and river mile 7W (RM 7W). RM 6.5W contained higher concentrations of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), but the diagnostic ratios of both extracts indicated similar PAH sourcing and composition. Developmental screens determined RM 6.5W to be more toxic with the most sensitive endpoint being a "wavy" notochord malformation. Differential gene expression from exposure to both extracts was largely parallel, although more pronounced for RM 6.5W. When compared to the gene expression associated with individual chemical exposures, PSD extracts produced some gene signatures parallel to PAHs but were more closely matched by oxygenated-PAHs. Additionally, differential expression, reminiscent of the wavy notochord phenotype, was not accounted for by either class of chemical, indicating the potential of other contaminants driving mixture toxicity. These techniques offer a compelling method for non-targeted hazard characterization of whole mixtures in an in vivo vertebrate system without requiring complete chemical characterization.
被动采样装置(PSD)与斑马鱼发育毒性试验相结合,是检测环境场所中与生物可利用非极性有机物相关的全混合物毒性的优秀传感器。我们通过在受精后48小时的斑马鱼中纳入RNA测序来扩展这一概念,这些斑马鱼静态暴露于来自波特兰港两个超级基金场地(6.5W河英里(RM 6.5W)和7W河英里(RM 7W))的PSD提取物中。RM 6.5W含有更高浓度的多环芳烃(PAHs),但两种提取物的诊断比率表明PAH来源和组成相似。发育筛查确定RM 6.5W毒性更大,最敏感的终点是“波浪状”脊索畸形。暴露于两种提取物后的差异基因表达在很大程度上是平行的,尽管RM 6.5W更为明显。与个体化学物质暴露相关的基因表达相比,PSD提取物产生了一些与PAHs平行的基因特征,但与氧化PAHs的匹配度更高。此外,与波浪状脊索表型相似的差异表达,这两类化学物质都无法解释,表明其他污染物可能导致混合物毒性。这些技术提供了一种令人信服的方法,可在体内脊椎动物系统中对全混合物进行非靶向危害特征分析,而无需完整的化学特征分析。