Thorson A G, Christensen M A, Davis S J
Dis Colon Rectum. 1986 May;29(5):306-11. doi: 10.1007/BF02554117.
A retrospective review of 176 patients with adenocarcinoma of the colon who underwent total colonoscopy preoperatively demonstrated synchronous carcinomas in 3.4 percent and synchronous polyps in 55.1 percent. Full-column barium enemas (68 patients) failed to identify cancer in 22 percent of patients and synchronous polyps in 58 percent of patients, a statistically significant (P less than 0.001) number of false-negative examinations. Double-contrast barium enemas (30 patients) failed to identify cancer in 27 percent of patients and synchronous polyps in 42 percent of patients, also a statistically significant (P less than 0.007) number of false-negative examinations. Full column and air contrast barium enemas identified all index cancers with distant metastases. Air-contrast barium enemas failed to identify 40 percent of "early" index cancers (confined to the bowel wall, negative nodes), and full-column barium enemas failed to identify 32 percent. The incidence of synchronous carcinoma and polyps underscores the need for total colon evaluation when a primary carcinoma is detected. Because of the poor accuracy of barium studies, total colonoscopy is the method of choice for this evaluation.
对176例术前接受全结肠镜检查的结肠癌患者进行回顾性研究发现,同时性癌的发生率为3.4%,同时性息肉的发生率为55.1%。全结肠钡灌肠检查(68例患者)未能发现22%患者的癌症以及58%患者的同时性息肉,假阴性检查数量具有统计学意义(P<0.001)。双重对比钡灌肠检查(30例患者)未能发现27%患者的癌症以及42%患者的同时性息肉,假阴性检查数量也具有统计学意义(P<0.007)。全结肠和气钡双重对比灌肠检查发现了所有伴有远处转移的原发癌。气钡双重对比灌肠检查未能发现40%的“早期”原发癌(局限于肠壁,淋巴结阴性),全结肠钡灌肠检查未能发现32%。同时性癌和息肉的发生率突出了在发现原发性癌时进行全结肠评估的必要性。由于钡剂检查准确性较差,全结肠镜检查是进行此项评估的首选方法。