Centre for Gerontology and Rehabilitation, School of Medicine, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
National Dementia Office, Health Service Executive, Tullamore, Ireland.
Drugs Aging. 2023 May;40(5):461-472. doi: 10.1007/s40266-023-01020-w. Epub 2023 Mar 30.
Psychotropic medications are commonly prescribed to people with dementia (PwD) for non-cognitive symptoms of dementia (NCSD), but have significant risks. A national audit was performed in acute hospitals in the Republic of Ireland (ROI) to establish baseline practice prior to the launch and implementation of a National Clinical Guideline on the appropriate prescribing of psychotropic medications for NCSD. The objective of this study was to analyse psychotropic prescribing patterns and compare these with international data and with existing (limited) data from a previous audit round.
The pooled anonymous dataset from the second round of the Irish National Audit of Dementia Care (INAD-2) was analysed. The audit had collected retrospective data from 30 random healthcare records from each of 30 acute hospitals in 2019. Inclusion criteria were a clinical diagnosis of dementia of any type, hospital stay of 72 hours or more, and discharge or death within the audit period. Most hospitals (87%) self-audited their healthcare records, but a random sample of six healthcare records (20%) from each hospital were re-audited by a highly trained healthcare auditor. The audit tool was based on a tool used in the England and Wales National Audit of Dementia audit rounds (Royal College of Psychiatrists), adapted to the Irish healthcare setting and national priorities.
In total, 893 cases were included, as one hospital could not retrieve 30 cases even within a more prolonged audit period. The sample comprised 55% females and 45% males; the median age was 84 years (interquartile range 79-88 years) and the majority (89.6%) were >75 years of age. Only 52% of healthcare records specified the type of dementia; within these, the most common diagnosis was Alzheimer's disease (45%). Most PwD (83%) were receiving psychotropic medication on admission; 40% were prescribed new or increased psychotropic medication during admission, mainly for medical indications, including end-of-life care and delirium. Anticonvulsants or cognitive enhancers were rarely prescribed for NCSD in hospital. However, new/increased antipsychotic medication was prescribed for NCSD in 11.8-17.6% of the total cohort, while 4.5-7.7% were prescribed a benzodiazepine for anxiety or NCSD. Overall, there was poor documentation of risk/benefit, or of discussion with the patient/family, and apparently inadequate review for efficacy and tolerability. Concurrently, acetylcholinesterase inhibitors appeared to be underused for cognitive impairment in the community.
This audit provides baseline data on psychotropic medication prescription for NCSD in Irish hospitals prior to a specific Irish guideline on this topic. Reflecting this, most PwD were receiving psychotropic medications on admission, and many were prescribed new/increased psychotropic medication in hospital, often without evidence of appropriate decision making and prescribing processes.
精神药物常用于治疗痴呆症患者(PwD)的非认知症状(NCSD),但存在显著风险。在爱尔兰共和国(ROI)的急性医院进行了一项全国性审计,以在发布和实施关于适当为 NCSD 开具精神药物的国家临床指南之前确定基线实践。本研究的目的是分析精神药物的开具模式,并将其与国际数据以及之前一轮审计中的现有(有限)数据进行比较。
对爱尔兰痴呆症护理国家审计(INAD-2)第二轮的汇总匿名数据集进行了分析。该审计从 2019 年的 30 家急性医院的每个医院随机抽取了 30 个医疗记录,收集了回顾性数据。纳入标准为任何类型的痴呆症的临床诊断、住院时间超过 72 小时、以及在审计期间出院或死亡。大多数医院(87%)自行审计其医疗记录,但每家医院随机抽取 6 份医疗记录(20%)由经过高度培训的医疗审计师进行重新审计。审计工具基于英格兰和威尔士国家痴呆症审计轮次(皇家精神病学院)使用的工具,适用于爱尔兰医疗保健环境和国家优先事项。
总共纳入了 893 例病例,因为有一家医院即使在更长的审计期内也无法检索到 30 例病例。样本包括 55%的女性和 45%的男性;中位年龄为 84 岁(四分位间距 79-88 岁),大多数(89.6%)年龄超过 75 岁。只有 52%的医疗记录指明了痴呆症的类型;在这些记录中,最常见的诊断是阿尔茨海默病(45%)。大多数 PwD(83%)在入院时正在服用精神药物;40%在入院期间因医疗原因,包括临终关怀和谵妄,开具了新的或增加的精神药物。抗惊厥药或认知增强剂很少用于医院的 NCSD。然而,在总队列中,有 11.8-17.6%的患者因 NCSD 开具了新的/增加的抗精神病药物,而 4.5-7.7%的患者因焦虑或 NCSD 开具了苯二氮䓬类药物。总体而言,对风险/获益的记录或与患者/家属的讨论以及对疗效和耐受性的评估显然不足。同时,乙酰胆碱酯酶抑制剂在社区中治疗认知障碍的应用似乎不足。
这项审计提供了爱尔兰医院治疗 NCSD 的精神药物处方的基线数据,在此之前,爱尔兰发布了关于该主题的具体指南。反映这一点的是,大多数 PwD 在入院时正在服用精神药物,许多人在医院开具了新的/增加的精神药物,通常没有适当的决策和处方流程的证据。