Centre for Infectious Disease Control, National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM), Antonie van Leeuwenhoeklaan 9, Bilthoven, 3720 MA, The Netherlands.
Department of Obstetrics, Wilhelmina Children's Hospital, University Medical Center Utrecht, and Utrecht University, Utrecht, the Netherlands.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Mar 30;23(1):311. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-09274-1.
Immunization of pregnant women with a tetanus-diphtheria-and-acellular-pertussis (Tdap) vaccine is an effective and safe way to protect infants from pertussis before their primary vaccinations. Vaccine uptake among pregnant women is influenced by their care providers' attitudes toward maternal vaccination. This qualitative study aimed to evaluate the implementation of the maternal Tdap vaccination under the National Immunization Program of the Netherlands from the perspective of obstetric care providers.
In this qualitative and explorative study, we conducted in-depth interviews by telephone with obstetric care providers who were selected from a pool of respondents (convenience sampling) to a questionnaire in a previous study. The interviews were based on a semi-structured interview guide that covered three aspects of the implementation strategy: providers' overall experience with the implementation of maternal Tdap vaccination in the Netherlands; implementation logistics and counseling, and pregnant women referrals to municipal Youth Healthcare Centers. The interviews were recorded, pseudonymized and transcribed verbatim. Transcripts were analyzed according to the Thematic Analysis approach by two researchers independently in two phases of iterative coding, categorizing, reviewing and redefining until ultimately, emergent themes regarding maternal Tdap vaccination implementation were identified.
Interviews with 11 midwives and 5 OB-GYN physicians yielded 5 major themes regarding the Tdap vaccination implementation strategy: challenges throughout the implementation process, views on maternal Tdap vaccination, general versus tailored counseling, provider responsibilities in vaccine promotion, and impact of materials for information delivery. Participants indicated that to improve provider attitudes toward Tdap vaccination, its implementation requires clear and transparent information about what is entailed, i.e., what is expected from obstetric care providers, how they can obtain information, and when their actions must be initiated. Participants demanded involvement throughout the implementation planning process. They preferred tailored communication with pregnant women over a generalized approach.
This study emphasized the importance of involving all relevant healthcare professionals in planning the implementation of maternal Tdap vaccination. Possible barriers perceived by these professionals should be taken into account in order to improve their attitudes toward vaccination, thus to increase uptake among pregnant women.
孕妇接种破伤风、白喉和无细胞百日咳(Tdap)疫苗是一种有效且安全的方法,可以在婴儿进行基础免疫接种之前预防百日咳。孕妇对疫苗的接受程度受到其医疗服务提供者对产妇疫苗接种态度的影响。本研究旨在从产科护理提供者的角度评估荷兰国家免疫计划中 Tdap 疫苗接种的实施情况。
在这项定性和探索性研究中,我们对先前一项问卷调查的回复者中选择的产科护理提供者进行了电话深度访谈(便利抽样)。访谈基于半结构化访谈指南,涵盖实施策略的三个方面:提供者在荷兰实施孕产妇 Tdap 疫苗接种的总体经验;实施后勤和咨询,以及向市青年保健中心转诊孕妇。访谈进行了录音,并进行了匿名化和逐字转录。两名研究人员在两个阶段独立地根据主题分析方法对转录本进行分析,该方法包括迭代编码、分类、审查和重新定义,直到最终确定关于孕产妇 Tdap 疫苗接种实施的主题。
对 11 名助产士和 5 名妇产科医生进行的访谈得出了 5 个关于 Tdap 疫苗接种实施策略的主要主题:实施过程中的挑战、对孕产妇 Tdap 疫苗接种的看法、一般与定制咨询、疫苗推广中的提供者责任以及信息传递材料的影响。参与者表示,为了改善提供者对 Tdap 疫苗接种的态度,其实施需要关于所涉及内容的明确和透明信息,即产科护理提供者的期望是什么,他们如何获取信息,以及他们的行动必须在何时开始。参与者要求在实施规划过程中全程参与。他们更喜欢针对孕妇的定制沟通,而不是一般性方法。
本研究强调了在规划孕产妇 Tdap 疫苗接种实施过程中让所有相关医疗保健专业人员参与的重要性。应该考虑这些专业人员认为的可能存在的障碍,以改善他们对疫苗接种的态度,从而提高孕妇的接种率。