Animal Welfare Program, Faculty of Land and Food Systems, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, V6T 1Z6, Canada.
ACER Consulting Inc., Guelph, ON, N1G 5L3, Canada.
J Dairy Sci. 2023 May;106(5):3548-3558. doi: 10.3168/jds.2022-22752. Epub 2023 Mar 29.
Surplus dairy calves and cull cows are often transported from the dairy farm to a variety of destinations and may experience compromised health and welfare in the process. Increasing interest in farm animal welfare by many stakeholders, including the public and policymakers, has brought about recent changes to livestock transport regulations in Canada that have likely affected transport operations across the country. The Atlantic region may be especially affected as a result of a smaller number of farms, and geography that often requires cattle to be transported long distances. We interviewed 7 livestock haulers in Atlantic Canada regarding their attitudes toward the recent changes to the transport regulations, particularly with regard to how these changes affected their business practices and dairy cattle welfare, as certain regulatory changes pertaining to calf transport were expected to disrupt existing transport practices. Thematic analysis of interview transcripts revealed 2 themes among participants: (1) calf (and sometimes adult cow) welfare and management during transport and on the dairy farm, and (2) feasibility of transport requirements and the enforcement of the regulations, including animosity toward other haulers and the challenge of satisfying both regulatory bodies and farmer clientele. These findings provide insight into the perspectives of an important, and often overlooked, stakeholder in the dairy industry on the transport system and highlight the need for inclusion of diverse voices when creating new policy.
过剩的奶牛小牛和淘汰奶牛经常从奶牛场运往各种目的地,在此过程中可能会健康和福利受损。许多利益相关者,包括公众和政策制定者,对农场动物福利的日益关注,导致加拿大最近对牲畜运输法规进行了修改,这可能影响了全国的运输业务。由于农场数量较少,以及经常需要长途运输牛的地理位置,大西洋地区可能受到的影响尤其大。我们采访了加拿大大西洋地区的 7 名牲畜运输商,了解他们对最近运输法规变化的态度,特别是这些变化如何影响他们的商业惯例和奶牛福利,因为预计与小牛运输有关的某些法规变化会扰乱现有的运输惯例。对访谈记录的主题分析揭示了参与者之间的 2 个主题:(1)运输过程中和奶牛场中小牛(有时是成年奶牛)的福利和管理,以及(2)运输要求的可行性和法规的执行情况,包括对其他运输商的敌意以及满足监管机构和农民客户双方的挑战。这些发现深入了解了奶牛行业中一个重要但经常被忽视的利益相关者对运输系统的看法,并强调在制定新政策时需要纳入不同的声音。