Geng Elvin H, Mody Aaloke, Powell Byron J
Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Medicine; and Center for Dissemination and Implementation, Institute for Public Health; Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, USA; email:
Center for Mental Health Services Research, Brown School, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
Annu Rev Public Health. 2023 Apr 3;44:21-36. doi: 10.1146/annurev-publhealth-051920-124515.
In many cases, implementation approaches (composed of one or more strategies) may need to change over time to work optimally. We use a literature review to inform a mechanistic analysis of such on-the-go adaptations. We suggest that such adaptations of implementation strategies consist of three necessary steps. The first component is the initial effect of the implementation approach on intended implementation, service delivery, or clinical outcomes. Second, these initial effects must in turn be used to modify, alter, intensify, or otherwise change the implementation approach. Third, the modified approach itself has effects. Conceiving of adaptation as all three steps implies that a full understanding of adaptation involves () a sense of initial effects, () conceptualizing and documenting content and rationale for changes in approach (e.g., alteration, intensification), and () the effects of the changed approach (including how the latter effects depend on initial effects). Conceptualizing these steps can help researchers ask questions about adaptation (e.g., thresholds for change, dosing, potentiation, sequencing) to advance our understanding of implementation strategies.
在许多情况下,实施方法(由一种或多种策略组成)可能需要随着时间的推移而改变,以实现最佳效果。我们通过文献综述为这种动态调整的机制分析提供信息。我们认为,这种实施策略的调整包括三个必要步骤。第一个组成部分是实施方法对预期实施、服务提供或临床结果的初始影响。其次,这些初始影响必须反过来用于修改、改变、强化或以其他方式改变实施方法。第三,修改后的方法本身会产生影响。将调整视为所有这三个步骤意味着,对调整的全面理解涉及()对初始影响的认识,()对方法变化(如改变、强化)的内容和理由进行概念化和记录,以及()改变后的方法的影响(包括后者的影响如何依赖于初始影响)。对这些步骤进行概念化可以帮助研究人员提出关于调整的问题(如变化阈值、剂量、增强作用、顺序),以增进我们对实施策略的理解。