Carotid endarterectomy in the octogenarian: is it appropriate?

To evaluate the role of carotid endarterectomy (CE) in patients 80 years and older an 8-year study of 172 nonrandomized cases of octogenarians with cerebrovascular disease was done. Ninety octogenarians underwent CE whereas 82 octogenarians, with arteriographically established carotid artery disease, were not operated on and served as a control series. The stroke rate after CE was 6%. In follow-up extending to 8 years the late stroke rate was only 2%, whereas the cumulative long-term stroke rate in the nonoperated group was 16%. These late strokes were appropriate to the side of the arteriographically demonstrated disease. In 1008 nonoctogenarians who underwent CE during this same time interval, the stroke rate after CE was 2% and the mortality rate was 0.6%. In the octogenarian population, however, the mortality rate after stroke was an alarming 40% in the operated group and 62% in the nonoperated control group. Arteriographic flow-limiting (greater than 75% stenosis) intracranial occlusive disease was identified in 53% of the octogenarians undergoing operation and in all patients who suffered a postoperative neurologic deficit. This incidence of severe intracranial disease was nearly five times that of the nonoctogenarian patients undergoing CE. Although the stroke rate after CE in the octogenarian patient was 6%, the late stroke rate was only 2% compared with the cumulative stroke rate of 16% in the nonoperated octogenarian patients. Severe intracranial occlusive disease and, therefore, flow deprivation may play a more significant role as a cause of postoperative deficits than in younger patients, but CE is appropriate for selected octogenarians on the basis of physiologic rather than chronologic age.