Division of Anatomy, Department of Human Morphology and Embryology, Faculty of Medicine, Wroclaw Medical University, Wroclaw, Poland.
Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Medicine, Wroclaw Medical University, Wroclaw, Poland.
J Anat. 2023 Jul;243(1):148-166. doi: 10.1111/joa.13854. Epub 2023 Apr 6.
Anatomical museums preserve specimens of great historical value and undiscovered scientific potential. However, frequently these collections lack documentation of the techniques of preparation and the composition of preservative substances (conservation principles). This poses a huge problem for the care and preservation of these materials, more so because understanding this issue requires knowledge of fundamentals from different scientific disciplines. The aim of the research was to obtain information about the composition of substances used to preserve historic specimens, as well as to conduct a microbiological assessment of the specimens to detect possible factors causing their deterioration. Furthermore, we wanted to fill an existing gap in the literature, as there is a lack of reports on analytical methods that could be successfully applied by anatomists involved in the daily care of museum collections in human anatomy departments. The starting point was the analysis of the sources and history of the collections, on which basis the choice of research methods was made. Methods based on simple chemical reactions and specialised methods (such as gas chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy) were used in the analyses of the composition of fluids. Microbiological analyses were based on culture and isolation methods, analysis of microscopy slides and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation time-of-flight mass spectrometry analysis. As a result of these analyses, some components of the preservative mixtures and their concentrations were determined. The presence of methanol, ethanol, formaldehyde and glycerol was detected, among other chemicals. The concentrations of these substances were different between the samples and their determination required the use of a variety of methods suitable for the individual components of the preservative mixture. In microbiological tests, both bacteria and fungi were isolated from swabs taken from anatomical specimens. The bacterial flora was less numerous than the fungal flora. Among the bacteria, environmental Gram-positive Bacillus cereus, Bacillus thuringiensis and a rare bacterium of the Cupriavidus genus were isolated, whereas among the fungal organisms, the yeast-like fungi Candida boidinii and Geotrichum silvicola as well as mould fungi Penicillium sp. and Fusarium sp. were detected. However, the microscopic evaluation showed a greater diversity of microorganisms, which may be related to the fact that many environmental bacteria cannot be cultured using classical methods, but can be observed under the microscope. The results of the research made it possible to draw conclusions about the mutual influence of physical, chemical, and microbiological factors on the condition of historical anatomical specimens. In the course of the research, information was obtained on the processes which could have taken place during the storage of these collections. Maintaining the integrity of a container housing a preserved anatomical specimen has a major impact on maintaining the concentration of preservative fluid and keeping the specimen environment sterile. Many conservation procedures for historical specimens carried out nowadays pose a risk of destroying valuable specimens, as well as a health risk for the person carrying out the work. The exploration of the topic of conservation of anatomical specimens, especially those that lack documentation of their origin, is a key issue in current research on historical collections of anatomical specimens.
解剖学博物馆保存着具有重要历史价值和尚未发现的科学潜力的标本。然而,这些藏品经常缺乏关于准备技术和防腐剂成分(保护原则)的记录。这对这些材料的护理和保存造成了巨大的问题,特别是因为理解这个问题需要来自不同科学学科的基础知识。研究的目的是获取有关用于保存历史标本的物质组成的信息,并对标本进行微生物评估,以发现可能导致其恶化的因素。此外,我们希望填补文献中的一个空白,因为缺乏关于分析方法的报告,而这些方法可能会被参与人体解剖学部门博物馆藏品日常护理的解剖学家成功应用。研究的起点是对藏品的来源和历史进行分析,在此基础上选择研究方法。在分析液体组成时使用了基于简单化学反应和专门方法(如气相色谱-串联质谱法、傅里叶变换红外光谱法、电感耦合等离子体光学发射光谱法)的方法。微生物分析基于培养和分离方法、显微镜载玻片分析和基质辅助激光解吸/离子化飞行时间质谱分析。根据这些分析,确定了防腐剂混合物的一些成分及其浓度。除其他化学物质外,还检测到甲醇、乙醇、甲醛和甘油的存在。这些物质的浓度在样品之间有所不同,其测定需要使用适合防腐剂混合物各个成分的各种方法。在微生物测试中,从解剖标本上的拭子中分离出细菌和真菌。细菌菌群比真菌菌群少。在细菌中,分离出环境革兰氏阳性芽孢杆菌、苏云金芽孢杆菌和一种罕见的 Cupriavidus 属细菌,而在真菌中,分离出酵母样真菌 Candida boidinii 和 Geotrichum silvicola 以及霉菌真菌青霉属和镰刀菌属。然而,显微镜评估显示微生物的多样性更大,这可能与以下事实有关,即许多环境细菌不能使用经典方法培养,但可以在显微镜下观察到。研究结果使我们能够得出关于物理、化学和微生物因素对历史解剖标本状况的相互影响的结论。在研究过程中,获得了有关这些藏品储存过程中可能发生的过程的信息。保持装有保存标本的容器的完整性对保持防腐剂液的浓度和保持标本环境无菌有重大影响。现在进行的许多历史标本保护程序会破坏有价值的标本,并对从事该工作的人的健康构成威胁。探索解剖标本保护主题,特别是那些缺乏其来源记录的标本,是当前历史解剖标本收藏研究的关键问题。