Valicente Vinicius M, Sharpe Kassidy B, Gletsu-Miller Nana, Running Cordelia A
Department of Nutrition Science Purdue University West Lafayette Indiana USA.
Current location, Department of Nutritional Sciences University of Georgia Athens Georgia USA.
J Sens Stud. 2023 Feb;38(1):e12803. doi: 10.1111/joss.12803. Epub 2022 Nov 25.
Sugar-sweetened beverage consumption contributes to obesity and related diseases. Fortunately, beverages with reduced sweetness are a growing category in the beverage industry. These lower sweetness products could be useful for reducing the total dietary intake of sugar, but publicly available data are sparse on how much sweetness can be reduced without the change becoming noticeable to consumers. We investigated the just noticeable difference (JND) in sweetness of a cola-flavored carbonated beverage. Two sensory tests were conducted to detect the JND from 12.00% w/w sucrose. In each test, we used cola-flavored seltzer water with five decreasing sucrose concentrations (test 1:8.02-12.00% w/w; test 2:10.21-12.00% w/w). In both tests, samples were paired with the 12.00% reference, and participants were instructed to identify the sweeter sample. Participants correctly identified the reference sample at 10.21% in test one ( = .0039) and at 10.89% ( = .014) in test two. The data indicate that in a cola beverage, sucrose can be reduced by ~9.25% of the original concentration (12.00-10.89% w/w) before the sweetness becomes apparent to consumers. However, further work should consider whether sugar reductions greater than 9.25% would be acceptable, even if the difference in sweetness is apparent.
These data could help researchers and industry product developers know how much sugar can be reduced from a cola-flavored beverage before the change is apparent to consumers.
饮用含糖饮料会导致肥胖及相关疾病。幸运的是,低甜度饮料在饮料行业中所占份额日益增加。这些低甜度产品可能有助于减少糖的总膳食摄入量,但关于甜度降低多少而消费者却不会察觉的公开数据却很少。我们研究了可乐味碳酸饮料甜度的最小可觉差(JND)。进行了两项感官测试以检测相对于12.00%(w/w)蔗糖的最小可觉差。在每次测试中,我们使用了蔗糖浓度逐渐降低的可乐味苏打水(测试1:8.02 - 12.00%(w/w);测试2:10.21 - 12.00%(w/w))。在两项测试中,样品都与12.00%的参比样品配对,并且指示参与者识别较甜的样品。在测试一中,参与者在蔗糖浓度为10.21%时正确识别出参比样品(P = 0.0039),在测试二中为10.89%(P = 0.014)。数据表明,对于可乐饮料,在甜度对消费者变得明显之前,蔗糖浓度可以从原始浓度(12.00%(w/w))降低约9.25%(降至10.89%(w/w))。然而,进一步的研究应考虑即使甜度差异明显,大于9.25%的糖减量是否会被接受。
这些数据可以帮助研究人员和行业产品开发人员了解在甜度变化对消费者变得明显之前,可乐味饮料可以减少多少糖。