Division of Oncology, Rambam Health Care Campus, Haifa, Israel.
Bruce Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Oncologist. 2023 May 8;28(5):e287-e294. doi: 10.1093/oncolo/oyad037.
Little is known about the impact of spiritual caregivers, psychologists, and social workers on desired end-of-life (EoL) medical outcomes, such as reduced use of aggressive care in the final 2 weeks of life, having more time between the last active oncological treatment and death, and increased hospice use.
We conducted a prospective study of 180 patients with cancer and their families, their interactions with social work, psychology, and spiritual care, and the above three treatment outcomes.
We found that having one or more spiritual care visits (adjusted odds ratio (AOR) = 2.02; P = .04), having more quality visits with the psychologist (P = .01), and speaking with someone about one's inner resources (AOR = 2.25; P = .03) all correlated with reduced EoL aggressive care. The key interventions correlating with increased time after final treatment were more visits with the spiritual caregiver or the social worker (AOR = 1.30; P < .001), and speaking about the medical treatment (AOR = 1.54; P < .001) and about interpersonal relationships (AOR = 2.28; P < .001). A subjectively good-quality connection with the spiritual caregiver correlated with increased hospice use (AOR = 10.00; P = .01).
Patients with cancer who availed themselves of the spiritual care, psychology, and social work services, each profession in distinct ways, had significantly different outcomes in their EoL medical treatment, including undergoing fewer futile aggressive measures, having more time after their last active treatment, and using hospice services more. These outcomes directly bear on improved quality of life and reduced costs.
对于精神关怀者、心理学家和社会工作者对期望的临终(EoL)医疗结果的影响,例如减少生命最后 2 周的积极治疗、在最后一次积极的肿瘤治疗和死亡之间有更多时间以及增加使用临终关怀,知之甚少。
我们对 180 名癌症患者及其家属进行了一项前瞻性研究,研究了他们与社会工作、心理和精神关怀的互动以及上述三种治疗结果。
我们发现,有一次或多次精神关怀访问(调整后的优势比(AOR)= 2.02;P =.04)、与心理学家进行更多的高质量访问(P =.01)以及与某人谈论内在资源(AOR = 2.25;P =.03)都与减少 EoL 积极治疗有关。与增加临终后时间相关的关键干预措施是与精神关怀者或社会工作者进行更多的访问(AOR = 1.30;P <.001),以及谈论医疗(AOR = 1.54;P <.001)和人际关系(AOR = 2.28;P <.001)。与精神关怀者建立主观上良好的关系与增加使用临终关怀相关(AOR = 10.00;P =.01)。
利用精神关怀、心理和社会工作服务的癌症患者,每个专业人员都以不同的方式,在他们的 EoL 医疗治疗中取得了明显不同的结果,包括接受更少的无效积极治疗、在最后一次积极治疗后有更多时间以及更多地使用临终关怀服务。这些结果直接影响到提高生活质量和降低成本。