Department of Anesthesiology & Critical Care, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.
Department of Perioperative & Procedural Services, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.
JAMA Netw Open. 2023 Apr 3;6(4):e237621. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.7621.
The perioperative environment is hazardous, but patients remain safe with a successful outcome during their care due to staff adaptability and resiliency. The behaviors that support this adaptability and resilience have yet to be defined or analyzed. One Safe Act (OSA), a tool and activity developed to capture self-reported proactive safety behaviors that staff use in their daily practice to promote individual and team-based safe patient care, may allow for improved definition and analysis of these behaviors.
To thematically analyze staff behaviors using OSA to understand what may serve as the basis for proactive safety in the perioperative environment.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This qualitative thematic analysis included a convenience sample of perioperative staff at a single-center, tertiary care academic medical center who participated in an OSA activity during a 6-month period in 2021. All perioperative staff were eligible for inclusion. A combined deductive approach, based on a human factor analysis and classification framework, as well as an inductive approach was used to develop themes and analyze the self-reported staff safety behaviors.
Those selected to participate were asked to join an OSA activity, which was conducted in-person by a facilitator. Participants were to self-reflect about their OSA (proactive safety behavior) and record their experience as free text in an online survey tool.
The primary outcome was the development and application of a set of themes to describe proactive safety behaviors in the perioperative environment.
A total of 140 participants (33 nurses [23.6%] and 18 trainee physicians [12.9%]), which represented 21.3% of the 657 total perioperative department full-time staff, described 147 behaviors. A total of 8 non-mutually exclusive themes emerged with the following categories and frequency of behaviors: (1) routine-based adaptations (46 responses [31%]); (2) resource availability and assessment adaptations (31 responses [21%]); (3) communication and coordination adaptation (23 responses [16%]); (4) environmental ergonomics adaptation (17 responses [12%]); (5) situational awareness adaptation (12 responses [8%]); (6) personal or team readiness adaptation (8 responses [5%]); (7) education adaptation (5 responses [3%]); and (8) social awareness adaptation (5 responses [3%]).
The OSA activity elicited and captured proactive safety behaviors performed by staff. A set of behavioral themes were identified that may serve as the basis for individual practices of resilience and adaptability that promote patient safety.
围手术期环境充满危险,但由于医护人员的适应能力和弹性,患者在接受治疗时仍能安全康复。支持这种适应能力和弹性的行为尚未得到定义或分析。一种安全行为(One Safe Act,OSA)是一种工具和活动,旨在捕捉员工在日常实践中主动报告的安全行为,以促进个人和团队为基础的安全患者护理,这可能有助于更好地定义和分析这些行为。
使用 OSA 对员工行为进行主题分析,以了解围手术期环境中主动安全的基础可能是什么。
设计、地点和参与者:这是一项定性主题分析,包括在 2021 年为期 6 个月期间在一家单中心三级保健学术医疗中心参加 OSA 活动的便利抽样围手术期工作人员。所有围手术期工作人员都有资格参加。采用基于人为因素分析和分类框架的演绎方法以及归纳方法来开发主题并分析自我报告的员工安全行为。
被选中参加的人被要求参加 OSA 活动,该活动由一名主持人进行现场指导。参与者被要求反思自己的 OSA(主动安全行为),并在在线调查工具中以自由文本记录他们的体验。
主要结果是制定和应用一套主题来描述围手术期环境中的主动安全行为。
共有 140 名参与者(33 名护士[23.6%]和 18 名受训医生[12.9%]),占 657 名全职围手术期部门工作人员的 21.3%,描述了 147 种行为。共出现 8 个非互斥主题,具有以下类别和行为频率:(1)基于常规的适应(46 次回应[31%]);(2)资源可用性和评估适应(31 次回应[21%]);(3)沟通和协调适应(23 次回应[16%]);(4)环境人体工程学适应(17 次回应[12%]);(5)情境意识适应(12 次回应[8%]);(6)个人或团队准备情况适应(8 次回应[5%]);(7)教育适应(5 次回应[3%]);(8)社会意识适应(5 次回应[3%])。
OSA 活动引发并捕捉了员工的主动安全行为。确定了一组行为主题,这些主题可能是促进患者安全的弹性和适应性的个人实践的基础。