Huang Dongmei, Wang Xinzhao, Chang Xikun, Qiao Shuyu, Zhu Yingying, Xing Daqian
State Key Laboratory of Mining Disaster Prevention and Control Co-Founded By Shandong Province and the Ministry of Science and Technology, Shandong University of Science and Technology, Qingdao, 266590, China.
College of Safety and Environmental Engineering, Shandong University of Science and Technology, Qingdao, 266590, China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2023 May;30(21):60746-60759. doi: 10.1007/s11356-023-26717-8. Epub 2023 Apr 11.
Filling mining is the main mining method in coal mine, and its safety is the pillar of the overall safety of the mine. Filling mining can effectively protect the surface environment, better solve the problem of ground pressure, and maximize the recovery of underground resources. Therefore, this method has an irreplaceable role in deep mining of coal mines and is highly valued by the mining industry all around the world. In order to evaluate the implementation effect of filling mining, a comprehensive weighting-set pair analysis safety evaluation model is established. This model optimizes the subjectivity of analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and the objectivity of Entropy Weight Method (EWM) in traditional methods. Besides, we add experts' weight to Entropy Weight Method. The combination of the two methods makes the index weight more reasonable and effective, and can more fully reflect the difference and correlation of index. Firstly, the accident causation analysis and taxonomy (ACAT) is used to find out the accident causation factors of filling mining, and then, the AHP and EWM are used to determine the weight of each evaluation index from different perspectives. Then, the evaluation group is established to score the importance of each expert, so as to reduce the subjectivity of expert scoring. Finally, according to the principle of set pair analysis, the safety evaluation model of filling mining is applied to Yuxing Coal Mine in Inner Mongolia. The evaluation result shows that the safety grade of this mine is grade 1 "safety." This paper provides a new way and direction for the comprehensive evaluation of similar mining methods, the establishment of index system, the acquisition of index weights, and the evaluation of safety level, which has promotion and application value.
充填开采是煤矿的主要开采方法,其安全性是矿井整体安全的支柱。充填开采能有效保护地表环境,更好地解决地压问题,并最大限度地回收地下资源。因此,该方法在煤矿深部开采中具有不可替代的作用,受到世界各国采矿业的高度重视。为评价充填开采的实施效果,建立了一种综合加权集对分析安全评价模型。该模型优化了传统方法中层次分析法(AHP)的主观性和熵权法(EWM)的客观性。此外,在熵权法中加入了专家权重。两种方法相结合使指标权重更加合理有效,能更充分地反映指标的差异和相关性。首先,运用事故致因分析与分类法(ACAT)找出充填开采的事故致因因素,然后,利用层次分析法和熵权法从不同角度确定各评价指标的权重。接着,建立评价小组对各专家的重要性进行打分,以降低专家打分的主观性。最后,根据集对分析原理,将充填开采安全评价模型应用于内蒙古玉星煤矿。评价结果表明,该矿安全等级为一级“安全”。本文为类似开采方法的综合评价、指标体系的建立、指标权重的获取以及安全水平的评价提供了新的途径和方向,具有推广应用价值。