Advocate Aurora Research Institute, Downers Grove, IL, USA.
Advocate Aurora Health, Downers Grove, IL; Milwaukee, WI, USA.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2023 Jan-Dec;14:21501319231164545. doi: 10.1177/21501319231164545.
The objective of the CONTINUE (conversations in routine OB care) pilot study was to gather preliminary data on the benefits of integrating a well-designed pregnancy support tool ("CONTINUE Tool") in low-income prenatal care. A total of 184 tools were distributed by 21 OB providers during the study implementation period. Follow-up data were collected from 71 (38.5%) prenatal patients across three community-based midwestern OB clinics serving a diverse prenatal patient population. Early-gestation prenatal patients received the strategically designed CONTINUE Tool during routine prenatal care and later completed a semi-structured interview or electronic survey to report pre-determined individual benefit items experienced due to tool usage. Factor analysis used individual benefit items to identify factors representing common underlying benefits ("factor benefits"). Logistic regression analyses were performed to describe the relative odds of participants with low income (public insurance) experiencing individual and factor benefits of tool use compared to participants of higher income (private insurance). Chi square tests (or Fisher's exact tests) were performed to generate values reflecting statistically significant differences by income group. More low-income prenatal participants reported experiencing individual benefits as compared to higher-income participants. Among factor benefits, low-income participants were statistically more likely to report experiencing a time-related logistics benefit (OR = 4.00; 95% CI 1.02-15.73; = .045). Low-income participants reported experiencing an overall logistics factor benefit (OR = 4.29; 95% CI 0.47-38.75), including a cost-related logistics benefit (OR = 3.08; CI 0.59-16.00), as well as an understanding benefit (OR = 1.90; 95% CI 0.72-5.04) and a self-efficacy benefit (OR = 1.30; 95% CI 0.44-3.87). While this study is limited by sample size due to being a pilot study, the findings suggest there may be tangible benefits to introducing the CONTINUE Tool among low-income prenatal patients. Given the staggering inequity in OB care and subsequent health outcomes, any preliminary findings on ways to help combat this are necessary and should lay the groundwork for subsequent randomized trials. Our preliminary findings show that supplementing routine OB care with the CONTINUE Tool can confer benefits to both providers and patients, but particularly for low-income prenatal patients who tend to have more structural barriers to adequate care in the first place.
本研究的目的是收集将精心设计的妊娠支持工具(CONTINUE 工具)整合到低收入产前护理中带来的益处的初步数据。在研究实施期间,共有 21 名 OB 提供者分发了 184 个工具。通过为服务于多样化产前患者人群的三家中西部社区 OB 诊所的 71 名(38.5%)产前患者收集了随访数据。早期妊娠的产前患者在常规产前护理期间收到了战略性设计的 CONTINUE 工具,然后完成了半结构化访谈或电子调查,以报告因工具使用而经历的预先确定的个人受益项目。因子分析使用个体受益项目来识别代表共同潜在受益的因素(“因子受益”)。进行逻辑回归分析以描述低收入(公共保险)参与者与高收入(私人保险)参与者相比,体验工具使用的个人和因子受益的相对优势。卡方检验(或 Fisher 精确检验)用于生成反映按收入组的统计显著差异的 值。与高收入参与者相比,更多的低收入产前参与者报告了个人受益。在因子受益方面,低收入参与者更有可能报告经历与时间相关的后勤受益(OR=4.00;95%CI 1.02-15.73;=0.045)。低收入参与者报告经历了整体后勤因素受益(OR=4.29;95%CI 0.47-38.75),包括与成本相关的后勤受益(OR=3.08;CI 0.59-16.00),以及理解受益(OR=1.90;95%CI 0.72-5.04)和自我效能受益(OR=1.30;95%CI 0.44-3.87)。虽然由于本研究是一项试点研究,因此样本量有限,但研究结果表明,在低收入产前患者中引入 CONTINUE 工具可能会带来切实的好处。鉴于 OB 护理和随后的健康结果存在巨大的不公平现象,任何有助于解决这一问题的初步发现都是必要的,应该为随后的随机试验奠定基础。我们的初步研究结果表明,在常规 OB 护理中补充 CONTINUE 工具可以为提供者和患者带来好处,但对于最初就存在获得充分护理的结构性障碍的低收入产前患者来说尤其如此。