Brown Evan C, Hallinger Daniel R, Simmons Steven O
Oak Ridge Institute for Science Education Fellow, Research Triangle Park, NC, United States.
Rapid Assay Development Branch, Biomolecular and Computational Toxicology Division, Center for Computational Toxicology and Exposure, Office of Research and Development, U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC, United States.
Front Toxicol. 2023 Apr 4;5:1134783. doi: 10.3389/ftox.2023.1134783. eCollection 2023.
Analysis of streamlined computational models used to predict androgen disrupting chemicals revealed that assays measuring androgen receptor (AR) cofactor recruitment/dimerization were particularly indispensable to high predictivity, especially for AR antagonists. As the original dimerization assays used to develop the minimal assay models are no longer available, new assays must be established and evaluated as suitable alternatives to assess chemicals beyond the original 1,800+ supported by the current data. Here we present the AR2 assay, which is a stable, cell-based method that uses an enzyme complementation approach. Bipartite domains of the NanoLuc luciferase enzyme were fused to the human AR to quantitatively measure ligand-dependent AR homodimerization. 128 chemicals with known endocrine activity profiles including 43 AR reference chemicals were screened in agonist and antagonist modes and compared to the legacy assays. Test chemicals were rescreened in both modes using a retrofit method to incorporate robust cytochrome P450 (CYP) metabolism to assess CYP-mediated shifts in bioactivity. The AR2 assay is amenable to high-throughput screening with excellent robust Z'-factors (rZ') for both agonist (0.94) and antagonist (0.85) modes. The AR2 assay successfully classified known agonists (balanced accuracy = 0.92) and antagonists (balanced accuracy = 0.79-0.88) as well as or better than the legacy assays with equal or higher estimated potencies. The subsequent reevaluation of the 128 chemicals tested in the presence of individual human CYP enzymes changed the activity calls for five compounds and shifted the estimated potencies for several others. This study shows the AR2 assay is well suited to replace the previous AR dimerization assays in a revised computational model to predict AR bioactivity for parent chemicals and their metabolites.
对用于预测雄激素干扰化学物质的简化计算模型的分析表明,测量雄激素受体(AR)辅因子募集/二聚化的检测方法对于高预测性尤为不可或缺,特别是对于AR拮抗剂。由于用于开发最小检测模型的原始二聚化检测方法已不再可用,因此必须建立并评估新的检测方法,作为合适的替代方法,以评估超出当前数据支持的原始1800多种化学物质之外的其他化学物质。在此,我们介绍AR2检测方法,这是一种基于细胞的稳定方法,采用酶互补方法。将纳米荧光素酶的二分结构域与人AR融合,以定量测量配体依赖性AR同源二聚化。在激动剂和拮抗剂模式下筛选了128种具有已知内分泌活性谱的化学物质,包括43种AR参考化学物质,并与传统检测方法进行了比较。使用改进方法在两种模式下对测试化学物质进行重新筛选,以纳入强大的细胞色素P450(CYP)代谢,以评估CYP介导的生物活性变化。AR2检测方法适用于高通量筛选,在激动剂(0.94)和拮抗剂(0.85)模式下均具有出色的稳健Z'因子(rZ')。AR2检测方法成功地对已知激动剂(平衡准确率 = 0.92)和拮抗剂(平衡准确率 = 0.79 - 0.88)进行了分类,与传统检测方法相当或更好,且估计效力相同或更高。随后在个体人CYP酶存在下对128种测试化学物质进行的重新评估改变了5种化合物的活性判定,并改变了其他几种化合物的估计效力。这项研究表明,AR2检测方法非常适合在修订的计算模型中取代以前的AR二聚化检测方法,以预测母体化学物质及其代谢物的AR生物活性。