Universidade do Estado do Rio de Janeiro, Pós Graduação em Fisiopatologia e Ciências Cirúrgicas, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein, São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
J Robot Surg. 2023 Aug;17(4):1809-1816. doi: 10.1007/s11701-023-01590-2. Epub 2023 Apr 21.
It is not established which factors impact the learning curve (LC) in robotic thoracic surgery (RTS), especially in emerging countries. The aim of this study is to analyze LC in RTS in Brazil and identify factors that can accelerate LC. We selected the first cases of two Brazilian surgeons who started their LC. We used CUSUM and the Lowess technique to measure LC for each surgeon and Poisson regression to assess factors associated with shorter console time (CT). 58 patients were operated by each surgeon and included in the analysis. Surgeries performed were different: Surgeon I (SI) performed 54 lobectomies (93.11%), whereas Surgeon II (SII) had a varied mix of cases. SI was proctored in his first 10 cases (17.24%), while SII in his first 41 cases (70.68%). The mean interval between surgeries was 8 days for SI and 16 days for SII. There were differences in the LC phases of the two surgeons, mainly regarding complications and conversions. There was shorter CT by 30% in the presence of a proctor, and by 20% with the Da Vinci Xi. Mix of cases did not seem to contribute to faster LC. Higher frequency between surgeries seems to be associated with a faster curve. Presence of proctor and use of bolder technologies reduced console time. We wonder if in phase 3 it is necessary to keep a proctor on complex cases to avoid serious complications. More studies are necessary to understand which factors impact the LC.
尚未确定哪些因素会影响机器人胸腔手术(RTS)的学习曲线(LC),尤其是在新兴国家。本研究旨在分析巴西 RTS 的 LC,并确定可以加速 LC 的因素。我们选择了两位开始进行 LC 的巴西外科医生的前几例患者。我们使用 CUSUM 和 Lowess 技术来衡量每位外科医生的 LC,并使用泊松回归来评估与控制台时间(CT)更短相关的因素。每位外科医生共进行了 58 例手术,这些手术都包含在分析中。手术类型有所不同:外科医生 I(SI)进行了 54 例肺叶切除术(93.11%),而外科医生 II(SII)则进行了各种不同的病例。SI 在他的前 10 例手术中接受了指导(17.24%),而 SII 在他的前 41 例手术中接受了指导(70.68%)。SI 两次手术之间的平均间隔为 8 天,SII 为 16 天。两位外科医生的 LC 阶段存在差异,主要是在并发症和转换方面。有指导时 CT 缩短了 30%,使用达芬奇 Xi 时 CT 缩短了 20%。混合病例似乎并没有加快 LC。手术之间的频率越高,曲线的速度就越快。有指导和使用更大胆的技术可以减少控制台时间。我们想知道在第 3 阶段,对于复杂病例是否有必要继续保留指导,以避免严重的并发症。还需要更多的研究来了解哪些因素会影响 LC。