Valizadeh Leila, Zamanzadeh Vahid, Namdar Areshtanab Hossein, Avazeh Marziyeh, Babaei Nasib
Department of Pediatric Nursing, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Department of Medical Surgical Nursing, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Heliyon. 2023 May;9(5):e15770. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e15770. Epub 2023 Apr 25.
Due to necessity of immediate support strategies for nurses during COVID-19 pandemic and lack of comprehensive and applied standard guidelines, the present study was conducted to develop stress management protocol for nurses working in COVID-19 wards with an approach based on the best scientific evidences.
This descriptive methodological and validation study was conducted with evidence-based approach based on Stetler model in two hospitals of Iran in 2020. In order to identify the resources of stress and the solutions provided to deal with it to design the protocol, a comprehensive literature review was performed. After extracting evidence, they were ranked based on the levels of evidence and designed as a protocol. Quality appraisal of guideline was done using AGREEII instrument by an expert panel. The applicability of the protocol was assessed by a group of nurses through focus group discussion.
Out of 184 studies, 28 articles related to the topic were selected. According to the expert panel, in the AGREEII domains, Scope and Purpose (87.5%) and Applicability (70.5%) were the highest and the lowest scores respectively. The "Stress Management Protocol for Nurses Working in COVID-19 Wards" was designed in six sections, which was elaborated relative to each stress resources. Members of the focus group mostly considered the evidence-based recommendations feasible by making suggestions to some items.
This study emphasized the important role of proper planning by health care system officials according to the designed protocol to manage stress and increase the self-efficacy of nurses in critical situations.
由于在新冠疫情期间需要为护士提供即时支持策略,且缺乏全面且实用的标准指南,本研究旨在基于最佳科学证据,为在新冠病房工作的护士制定压力管理方案。
本描述性方法学及验证性研究于2020年在伊朗的两家医院采用基于斯特勒模型的循证方法进行。为了确定压力源及应对压力的解决方案以设计方案,进行了全面的文献综述。提取证据后,根据证据水平进行排序并设计成方案。由专家小组使用AGREEII工具对指南进行质量评估。一组护士通过焦点小组讨论评估方案的适用性。
在184项研究中,选取了28篇与该主题相关的文章。根据专家小组的评估,在AGREEII各领域中,范围和目的(87.5%)得分最高,适用性(70.5%)得分最低。“新冠病房护士压力管理方案”分为六个部分,并针对每个压力源进行了详细阐述。焦点小组的成员大多认为通过对一些项目提出建议,循证建议是可行的。
本研究强调了医疗系统官员根据设计的方案进行适当规划对于管理压力和提高护士在危急情况下自我效能的重要作用。