Borges Pamela C C, Spencer Hirondina B, Barbosa Carla, Costa Victor, Furtado Antónia, Leal Maria Conceição, Lopes Carlos, Ferreira Dylan, Carvalho André Lopes, Dos-Santos-Silva Isabel, Santos Lúcio Lara
Laboratório Biologia Molecular, Hospital Universitário Agostinho Neto, Praia, Plateau 112, Cabo Verde.
Hospital Universitário Agostinho Neto, Praia, Plateau 112, Cabo Verde.
Ecancermedicalscience. 2023 Apr 11;17:1530. doi: 10.3332/ecancer.2023.1530. eCollection 2023.
Breast cancer (BC) is a public health problem in developing countries, including Cape Verde. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) is the gold standard technique used for BC phenotypic characterisation to support efficient therapeutic decisions. However, IHC is a demanding technique that requires knowledge, trained technicians, expensive antibodies and reagents, controls, and results validation. The low number of cases in Cape Verde increases the risk of expiring the validity of the antibodies, and manual procedures often jeopardise the quality of the results. Thus, IHC is limited in Cape Verde, and an alternative technically easy solution is needed. A point-of-care messenger RNA (mRNA) STRAT4 BC assay to assess estrogen (ER), progesterone (PR), hormone growth factor 2 receptor (HER2), and Ki67, using the GeneXpert platform, has been recently validated on tissues from internationally accredited laboratories, showing excellent concordance with IHC results.To assess whether this technology can be implemented in Cape Verde to guide BC treatment we decided to study the level of agreement between the findings yielded by BC STRAT4 and the results are the same cases obtained by IHC.
Formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue samples from 29 Cabo Verdean BC patients diagnosed in Agostinho Neto University Hospital were analysed by applying IHC and BC STRAT4 assay. The time between sample collection and pre-analytic procedures is unknown. All the samples were pre-processed in Cabo Verde (fixed in formalin and embedded in paraffin). IHC studies were performed in referenced laboratories in Portugal. STRAT4 and IHC result concordance was assessed by calculating the percentage of results agreement and Cohen's Kappa (K) statistics.
STRAT4 assay failed in 2 out of the 29 analysed samples. Of the 27 successfully analysed samples, STRAT4/IHC results for ER, PR, HER2, and Ki67 were concordant in 25, 24, 25, and 18 cases, respectively. Ki67 was indeterminate in three cases, and PR was indeterminate once.The percentage of agreement between STRAT4 and IHC results for ER, PR, HER2, and Ki67 was 92.59%, 92.31%, 92.59% and 81.82%, respectively. The Cohen's K statistic coefficients for each biomarker were 0.809, 0.845, 0.757 and 0.506, respectively.
According to our preliminary results, a point-of-care mRNA STRAT4 BC assay may be an alternative in laboratories unable to provide quality and/or cost-efficient IHC services. However, more data and improvement on sample pre-analytic processes are required to implement this BC STRAT4 Assay in Cape Verde.
乳腺癌(BC)在包括佛得角在内的发展中国家是一个公共卫生问题。免疫组织化学(IHC)是用于乳腺癌表型特征鉴定以支持有效治疗决策的金标准技术。然而,免疫组织化学是一项要求较高的技术,需要专业知识、训练有素的技术人员、昂贵的抗体和试剂、对照以及结果验证。佛得角的病例数量较少增加了抗体有效期过期的风险,而且手工操作常常会影响结果的质量。因此,免疫组织化学在佛得角受到限制,需要一种技术上简便的替代解决方案。一种用于评估雌激素(ER)、孕激素(PR)、激素生长因子2受体(HER2)和Ki67的即时护理信使核糖核酸(mRNA)STRAT4乳腺癌检测方法,使用GeneXpert平台,最近已在国际认可实验室的组织上得到验证,显示出与免疫组织化学结果高度一致。为了评估这项技术是否可以在佛得角实施以指导乳腺癌治疗,我们决定研究乳腺癌STRAT4检测结果与免疫组织化学在相同病例中获得的结果之间的一致性水平。
对在阿戈斯蒂纽·内托大学医院诊断的29例佛得角乳腺癌患者的福尔马林固定石蜡包埋(FFPE)组织样本进行免疫组织化学和乳腺癌STRAT4检测分析。样本采集与分析前程序之间的时间未知。所有样本均在佛得角进行预处理(用福尔马林固定并石蜡包埋)。免疫组织化学研究在葡萄牙的参考实验室进行。通过计算结果一致率和科恩卡帕(K)统计量来评估STRAT4与免疫组织化学结果的一致性。
在29份分析样本中,有2份STRAT4检测失败。在27份成功分析的样本中,ER、PR、HER2和Ki67的STRAT4/免疫组织化学结果分别在25例、24例、25例和18例中一致。Ki67在3例中结果不确定,PR有1例结果不确定。STRAT4与免疫组织化学在ER、PR、HER2和Ki67结果上的一致率分别为92.59%、92.31%、92.59%和81.82%。每个生物标志物的科恩K统计系数分别为0.809、0.845、0.757和0.506。
根据我们的初步结果,即时护理mRNA STRAT4乳腺癌检测方法可能是无法提供高质量和/或成本效益高的免疫组织化学服务的实验室的一种替代方法。然而,在佛得角实施这种乳腺癌STRAT4检测方法还需要更多数据以及对样本分析前处理过程进行改进。