Department of Automation, Tsinghua University, No. 168 Li Tang Road, Changping District, Beijing, 100084, China.
Department of Cardiology, School of Clinical Medicine, Beijing Tsinghua Changgung Hospital, Tsinghua University, No. 168 Li Tang Road, Changping District, Beijing, 102218, China.
BMC Anesthesiol. 2023 May 9;23(1):160. doi: 10.1186/s12871-023-02118-9.
To examine the prognostic value of HRV measurements during anesthesia for postoperative clinical outcomes prediction using machine learning models.
VitalDB, a comprehensive database of 6388 surgical patients admitted to Seoul National University Hospital.
Cases with ECG lead II recording duration of less than one hour were excluded. Cases with more than 20% of missing HRV measurements were also excluded. A total of 5641 cases were eligible for the analyses.
Six machine learning models including Logistic Regression (LR), Support Vector Machine (SVM), Random Forest (RF), Gradient Boosting Decision Trees (GBT), Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGB), and an ensemble of the five baseline models were developed to predict postoperative clinical outcomes. The prediction models were trained using only clinical information, and using both clinical information and HRV features, respectively. Feature importance based on the SHAP method was used to assess the contribution of the HRV measurements to the outcome predictions. Subgroup analysis was also performed to evaluate the risk association between postoperative ICU stay and various HRV measurements such as heart rate, low-frequency power (LFP), and short-term fluctuation DFA [Formula: see text].
The final cohort included 5641 unique cases, among whom 4678 (83.0%) cases had ages over 40, 2877 (51.0%) were male, 1073 (19.0%) stayed in ICU after surgery, 52 (0.9%) suffered in-hospital death, and 3167(56.1%) had a total length of hospital stay longer than 7 days. In the final test set, the highest AUROC performance with only clinical information was 0.79 for postoperative ICU stay, 0.58 for in-hospital mortality, and 0.76 for the total length of hospital stay prediction. Importantly, using both clinical information and HRV features, the AUROC performance was 0.83, 0.70, and 0.76 for the three clinical outcome predictions, respectively. Subgroup analysis found that patients with an average heart rate higher than 70, low-frequency power (LFP) < 33, and short-term fluctuation DFA [Formula: see text] < 0.95 during anesthesia, had a significantly higher risk of entering the ICU after surgery.
This study suggested that HRV measurements during anesthesia are feasible and effective for predicting postoperative clinical outcomes.
使用机器学习模型研究麻醉过程中心率变异性(HRV)测量对术后临床结局的预测价值。
VitalDB,这是一个包含 6388 名首尔国立大学医院住院手术患者的综合数据库。
排除心电图导联 II 记录时间不足 1 小时的病例,以及 HRV 测量缺失率超过 20%的病例。共有 5641 例病例符合分析要求。
采用逻辑回归(LR)、支持向量机(SVM)、随机森林(RF)、梯度提升决策树(GBT)、极端梯度提升(XGB)和 5 个基线模型的集成等 6 种机器学习模型预测术后临床结局。这些预测模型仅使用临床信息进行训练,也分别使用临床信息和 HRV 特征进行训练。使用 SHAP 方法进行特征重要性评估,以评估 HRV 测量对结局预测的贡献。还进行了亚组分析,以评估与术后 ICU 入住相关的风险关联以及各种 HRV 测量值,如心率、低频功率(LFP)和短期波动 DFA [公式:见文本]。
最终队列纳入了 5641 例独特的病例,其中 4678 例(83.0%)年龄超过 40 岁,2877 例(51.0%)为男性,1073 例(19.0%)术后入住 ICU,52 例(0.9%)院内死亡,3167 例(56.1%)住院总天数超过 7 天。在最终测试集中,仅使用临床信息时,术后 ICU 入住、院内死亡率和住院总天数预测的最高 AUROC 性能分别为 0.79、0.58 和 0.76。重要的是,同时使用临床信息和 HRV 特征时,三种临床结局预测的 AUROC 性能分别为 0.83、0.70 和 0.76。亚组分析发现,麻醉期间平均心率高于 70、低频功率(LFP)<33 和短期波动 DFA [公式:见文本] < 0.95 的患者术后入住 ICU 的风险显著增加。
本研究表明,麻醉过程中的 HRV 测量值可用于预测术后临床结局,具有可行性和有效性。