Kalke Paul, Beckers Patrick, Helm Conrad
Department of Animal Evolution and Biodiversity, University of Goettingen, Goettingen, Germany.
Institute of Evolutionary Biology and Ecology, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
BMC Zool. 2021 Nov 16;6(1):30. doi: 10.1186/s40850-021-00094-6.
Head appendages in Annelida contribute significantly to the immense morphological diversity in this spiralian taxon. Nevertheless, the evolutionary origin of annelid antennae, palps, cirri and tentacles are part of vast theories and debates that took place over decades. One of these heavily discussed groups are the Terebelliformia, which bear numerous anterior tentacles originating from different regions of the head. The question, whether these tentacles are homologous to feeding palps in other annelids or if these structures evolved convergently in terebellids and the remaining taxa, has been highly debated in the past.
By using morphological methods including immunohistochemistry, confocal microscopy, Azan-stained serial sections and 3D-visualisation, we are able to shed new light and a fresh look on the old question of the evolutionary origin of the buccal tentacles and their associated head structures in Terebelliformia. Our investigations show that the brains of the ampharetid Hypania invalida and the aulophora larvae of Lanice conchilega (Terebellidae) consist of a dorsal, more prominent and a more slender, ventral brain region. Neurite bundles innervating the buccal tentacles split off from the ventral and dorsal root within the ventral brain region and thus originate from the dorsal and ventral root of the circumoesophageal connectives. Hence, the observed neurite bundles fulfil the morphological criteria for the innervating neurite bundles of feeding palps known from Paleoannelida.
We disagree with former conclusions that buccal tentacles are part of the alimentary canal. Based on the presented data, the buccal tentacles of terebelliform taxa are innervated by neurite bundles and can be homologized with peristomial feeding palps of other Annelida. Our comparative investigations reveal important insights into morphological changes during the evolution of anterior head appendages in Terebelliformia and Annelida in general. Nevertheless, our analyses also illustrate the gaps in knowledge and that more investigations throughout the annelid tree are necessary to explain and understand the huge diversity of annelid anterior appendages.
环节动物的头部附属结构对这一螺旋类分类群中巨大的形态多样性有显著贡献。然而,环节动物触角、触须、刚毛和触手的进化起源是几十年来众多理论和争论的一部分。其中一个被大量讨论的类群是缨鳃虫类,它们有许多起源于头部不同区域的前部触手。这些触手是否与其他环节动物的摄食触须同源,或者这些结构在缨鳃虫类和其他类群中是趋同进化的,这个问题在过去一直备受争议。
通过使用包括免疫组织化学、共聚焦显微镜、偶氮染色连续切片和三维可视化在内的形态学方法,我们能够对缨鳃虫类口触手及其相关头部结构的进化起源这一古老问题有新的认识和新的看法。我们的研究表明,双鳃虫属的Hypania invalida和盘管虫属的Lanice conchilega(缨鳃虫科)的奥洛弗拉幼虫的脑由一个背侧更突出和一个更细长的腹侧脑区组成。支配口触手的神经纤维束在腹侧脑区内从腹根和背根分出,因此起源于围食管神经连合的背根和腹根。因此,观察到的神经纤维束符合古环节动物已知的摄食触须支配神经纤维束的形态学标准。
我们不同意以前关于口触手是消化道一部分的结论。根据所提供的数据,缨鳃虫类分类群的口触手由神经纤维束支配,并且可以与其他环节动物的围口摄食触须同源。我们的比较研究揭示了缨鳃虫类和一般环节动物前头部附属结构进化过程中形态变化的重要见解。然而,我们的分析也说明了知识上的差距,并且有必要对整个环节动物谱系进行更多的研究,以解释和理解环节动物前附属结构的巨大多样性。