Menabò Laura, Skrzypiec Grace, Slee Phillip, Guarini Annalisa
Department of Psychology "Renzo Canestrari", University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Department of Education, Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2025 Jun;95(2):249-269. doi: 10.1111/bjep.12604. Epub 2023 Apr 26.
Bullying and cyberbullying are serious public health concerns that involve more roles beyond the bully and the victim (pro-bullies, defenders, bystanders). However, students often perceive the phenomena as dyadic.
The purpose was to examine students' perceptions of different roles when observing bullying and cyberbullying scenes combining implicit (attention by using the eye-tracker) and explicit (verbal reports) measures.
We included 50 Italian students (aged 10-11).
Students watched 12 drawings of different types of bullying and cyberbullying while their gaze was tracked, and subsequently described each drawing verbally. We ran repeated measure ANOVAs to compare attentional indexes (fixation count, visit count and total fixation duration) in observing roles and Cochran's Q test to evaluate differences in the verbal identification of roles.
Overall, the victim and bully were the most observed and identified roles in every type of bullying and cyberbullying scenario. Concerning the other roles, a discrepancy was observed between the implicit and explicit measures since although it was greatly identified, the pro-bully received less attention, and while the bystander received great attention, it was mentioned less. Finally, the defender was more observed and identified in physical bullying and cyberbullying.
Our study points out for the first time the dyadic perception of the phenomena among adolescents using implicit and explicit measures and sheds light on differences among the roles in different forms of bullying. Further research including the eye-tracker would be worthwhile given the possibility of exploring the phenomena from different perspectives.
欺凌和网络欺凌是严重的公共卫生问题,涉及欺凌者和受害者之外的更多角色(支持欺凌者、维护者、旁观者)。然而,学生们常常将这些现象视为二元关系。
本研究旨在通过结合隐性(使用眼动仪记录注意力)和显性(口头报告)测量方法,考察学生在观察欺凌和网络欺凌场景时对不同角色的认知。
我们纳入了50名意大利学生(年龄在10 - 11岁)。
学生们观看12幅不同类型的欺凌和网络欺凌图画,同时记录他们的注视情况,随后对每幅图画进行口头描述。我们采用重复测量方差分析来比较观察不同角色时的注意力指标(注视次数、访问次数和总注视时长),并使用 Cochr an Q检验来评估不同角色口头识别的差异。
总体而言,在各类欺凌和网络欺凌场景中,受害者和欺凌者是被观察和识别最多的角色。对于其他角色,隐性和显性测量之间存在差异,因为尽管支持欺凌者被大量识别,但受到的关注较少,而旁观者受到的关注较多,但被提及较少。最后,在身体欺凌和网络欺凌中,维护者被观察和识别得更多。
我们的研究首次指出了青少年使用隐性和显性测量方法对这些现象的二元认知,并揭示了不同形式欺凌中各角色之间的差异。鉴于有可能从不同角度探索这些现象,进一步纳入眼动仪的研究是值得的。