Alsinai Aisha, Reygers Max, DiMascolo Lisa, Kafka Julie, Rowhani-Rahbar Ali, Adhia Avanti, Bowen Deirdre, Shanahan Sandra, Dalve Kimberly, Ellyson Alice M
Firearm Injury & Policy Research Program, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Front Sociol. 2023 Apr 28;8:1146102. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2023.1146102. eCollection 2023.
In the context of domestic violence (DV), immigration-related circumstances can be exploited by an abuser to coerce and manipulate their partner. Using an intersectional structural framework, we examine how social structures overlaid with immigration-specific experiences operate to further enhance opportunities for abuse against immigrant women. We conducted a textual analysis to identify how socially constructed systems interact with a victim-survivor's immigration status to introduce more tools for abusers to engage in coercive control and/or acts of violence in a random sample of petitioners (i.e., victim-survivors) who were granted a Domestic Violence Protection Order (DVPO) in King County, WA ( = 3,579) from 2014-2016 and 2018-2020. We hand-reviewed textual petitioner narratives and identified = 39 cases that discussed immigration-related circumstances and related acts of violence and coercion. These narratives included threats to contact authorities to interfere with an ongoing immigration process, deportation threats, and threats that would separate families. In many cases, petitioners indicated that immigration-related threats prevented them from leaving the violent partner, seeking help, or reporting the abuse. We also found mention of barriers for victims to receive protection and gain autonomy from further abuse including a lack of familiarity with US protections and laws, and restrictions on authorizations to work. These findings demonstrate that structurally created immigration-specific circumstances provide opportunities for threats and retaliation against victim-survivors by abusers and create barriers to seeking help initially. Policy should respond to anticipate these threats in the immigrant community and engage early responders (e.g., healthcare providers, law enforcement) to support victim-survivors from immigrant communities.
在家庭暴力(DV)的背景下,施虐者可能会利用与移民相关的情况来胁迫和操纵其伴侣。我们运用交叉性结构框架,研究叠加了特定移民经历的社会结构如何进一步增加对移民妇女的虐待机会。我们进行了文本分析,以确定社会建构的系统如何与受害者 - 幸存者的移民身份相互作用,从而为施虐者提供更多手段,以便在华盛顿州金县(2014 - 2016年和2018 - 2020年)获得家庭暴力保护令(DVPO)的随机样本请愿者(即受害者 - 幸存者)中实施强制控制和/或暴力行为。我们人工审阅了请愿者的文本叙述,确定了39个讨论与移民相关情况以及相关暴力和胁迫行为的案例。这些叙述包括威胁联系当局以干扰正在进行的移民程序、驱逐威胁以及会导致家庭分离的威胁。在许多情况下,请愿者表示与移民相关的威胁使他们无法离开暴力伴侣、寻求帮助或报告虐待行为。我们还发现提到了受害者在获得保护和摆脱进一步虐待方面面临的障碍,包括对美国保护措施和法律缺乏了解以及工作授权方面的限制。这些发现表明,结构性造成的特定移民情况为施虐者对受害者 - 幸存者进行威胁和报复提供了机会,并在最初寻求帮助时设置了障碍。政策应做出回应,预见到移民社区中的这些威胁,并让早期响应者(如医疗保健提供者、执法人员)参与进来,以支持移民社区的受害者 - 幸存者。