Department of Psychology, Capilano University, North Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Department of Psychology, Birmingham City University, Birmingham, UK.
Int J Psychol. 2023 Oct;58(5):415-423. doi: 10.1002/ijop.12916. Epub 2023 May 15.
Previous work suggests that people have a need for meaning, and that when meaning is threatened, efforts are undertaken to restore a sense of meaning. We hypothesized that a meaning threat (i.e., reminders of death) would increase victim blaming of a domestic violence victim since doing so can restore a sense of meaning-that people get what they deserve-but for those with advanced knowledge of victimology, such as trained counsellors, this effect would be diminished since victim blaming runs counter to their meaning framework that bad things can happen to good people. In addition, because art can provide a sense of meaning, we hypothesized that either creating meaningful art or observing art and finding meaning within it would diminish blaming a domestic violence victim since having a sense of meaning should diminish the need to restore meaning via victim blaming. Over five studies with undergraduate and trained counsellors, we found support for the hypotheses, and a meta-analysis on the victim blaming effect suggested a small, though significant, effect size of d = .28. These findings enhance our understanding of various factors that affect victim blaming, and they point towards relatively easy to administer interventions to diminish it.
先前的研究表明,人们有追求意义的需求,而当意义受到威胁时,人们会努力恢复意义感。我们假设,意义威胁(即死亡提醒)会增加对家庭暴力受害者的指责,因为这样做可以恢复一种意义感,即人们得到了应得的报应——但对于那些对受害者学有深入了解的人,如受过训练的顾问来说,这种影响会减弱,因为指责受害者违背了他们的意义框架,即好人也可能遭遇坏事。此外,由于艺术可以提供意义感,我们假设创作有意义的艺术作品或观察艺术并从中找到意义,会减少对家庭暴力受害者的指责,因为有意义感应该会减少通过指责受害者来恢复意义的需求。在五个包括本科生和受过训练的顾问的研究中,我们发现这些假设得到了支持,对指责受害者效应的元分析表明,d 值为.28,尽管效应较小,但具有统计学意义。这些发现增进了我们对影响指责受害者的各种因素的理解,并指出了相对容易实施的干预措施,可以减少这种指责。